Browsed by
Category: Original Reviews

Responses to Peary’s “must see” movie reviews, as well as my own “must see” movie reviews up to and after 1986 (when Peary’s book was published).

Death of a Gunfighter (1969)

Death of a Gunfighter (1969)

“I tried my damnedest to not kill him!”

Synopsis:
When a marshal (Richard Widmark) kills a drunken civilian (Jimmy Lydon) in self-defense, the entire town decides to fire him from his job — but Widmark isn’t interested in leaving town.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Don Siegel Films
  • John Saxon Films
  • Lena Horne Films
  • Richard Widmark Films
  • Sheriffs and Marshals
  • Westerns

Review:
This decent if uneven western is primarily notable for what it prompted: the creation of “Alan Smithee” as a pseudonym for a director whose actual director (or some other key player) doesn’t want to be associated with the film. In this case, Widmark didn’t get along with the original director, Robert Totten (who primarily worked in television), so Don Siegel was brought in to finish up the job — but he didn’t want to take credit for work mostly completed by someone else, so “Alan Smithee” (a creative variation on the too-simple first pass try of “Al Smith”) was the result.

(I find it interesting that this film is about attempting to fire someone perceived as incompetent in his job given what it became known for.)

Perhaps I was unduly biased, but as soon as I saw Smithee’s name flashing across the screen, I started noticing the film’s clunkiness; indeed, many wonder what this film could have been like with Siegel at the helm the entire way.

The storyline — hinging on an entire town feeling resentment for Widmark’s character, for no clear reason — doesn’t quite hold its weight; though Kent Smith, who film fanatics should fairly quickly recognize from Cat People (1942), plays the role of a desperately ashamed lawyer quite well.

The film is also notable for featuring Lena Horne in a supporting role as Widmark’s girlfriend, without any comment on her race.

Watch for Royal Dano hovering menacingly (what else?) around the periphery:

… and John Saxon as a county sheriff brought in to help mediate the situation.

Note: Subtle yet overt antisemitism is briefly shown through the treatment of the town’s “peddler,” Mr. Rosenbloom (David Opatoshu) — though it’s simply included without any explanation or resolution.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Richard Widmark as the Marshal
  • Kent Smith as Andrew Oxley
  • Fine Technicolor cinematography

Must See?
No, though it’s worth a look for curiosity’s sake (and of course Siegel completists will want to check it out).

Links:

Coming Apart (1969)

Coming Apart (1969)

“I like to photograph things as they happen; I’m interested in reality.”

Synopsis:
A self-absorbed, soon-to-be-divorced psychotherapist (Rip Torn) on the verge of a mental breakdown places a video camera in his office and secretly records his interactions (primarily sexual) with a variety of neurotic women.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Mental Breakdown
  • Peeping Toms
  • Psychotherapy
  • Rip Torn Films
  • Womanizers

Review:
Made in a similar vein as Jim McBride’s David Holzman’s Diary (1968), this faux documentary by writer-director Milton Moses Ginsberg was filmed in one room at Kips Bay Towers in New York City, and seems explicitly designed to exploit both a narcissist’s interest in chronicling their every move — welcome to the 21st century! — and the depravity of non-consenting voyeurism. It’s a laborious affair to sit through, for all sorts of reasons — primarily Torn’s character (Joe) being such an ass, but also because so much of what we see and hear is either boring and/or demeaning — and only rarely mildly amusing.

Writing about this film for the SF Gate in 1999, Edward Guthmann noted:

Time capsules can be embarrassing things. What once seemed hip and cutting-edge can reveal, after 30 years, a naivete and smug narcissism that wasn’t apparent at the time. That’s certainly the case with “Coming Apart,” an underground film that broke new ground with nudity and raw language and attempted to say something about the fallout of the sexual revolution. Starring Rip Torn and Sally Kirkland, “Coming Apart” opened in 1969 — the same year as “Easy Rider,” “Medium Cool” and “Midnight Cowboy” — but disappeared after the critics ground it up into pieces.

Rightfully so; check out Andrew Harris’s review in The Village Voice for a particularly lambasting take. For the record, notable supporting actors in this film include Viveca Lindfors as Joe’s former lover (trying to remind him about the “former” part):

…. and Sally Kirkland as an unhinged and exhibitionist former patient.

Note: Ginsberg’s only other film was The Werewolf of Washington (1973).

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Occasionally creative cinematic moves

Must See?
Nope; skip this one unless you’re curious. Listed as a Cult Movie in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

That Cold Day in the Park (1969)

That Cold Day in the Park (1969)

“I saw you from my apartment; I’ve been watching you in the rain.”

Synopsis:
When a wealthy spinster (Sandy Dennis) invites a shivering young man (Michael Burns) she sees in the park over to her apartment, a bizarre relationship quickly ensues.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Michael Murphy Films
  • Obsessive Love
  • Psychological Horror Films
  • Robert Altman Films
  • Sandy Dennis Films

Review:
Robert Altman’s final early feature before his breakthrough success with M*A*S*H (1970) — after helming The James Dean Story (1957), The Delinquents (1957), Countdown (1968), and quite a few TV episodes and industrial flicks — was this adaptation of an unpublished novel by Peter Miles, about a lonely woman whose concern for a bedraggled young man she sees outside her apartment window:

… turns into a most unusual series of events and circumstances. To the immense credit of the screenplay, we are kept on our toes throughout, sincerely wondering where in the world things will lead — and it’s most often not where we expected.

Dennis seems perfectly content simply caring for Burns, not minding too much that he is completely mute; indeed, this provides the perfect opportunity to bare her soul.

Horror-like elements are introduced from fairly early on (about 25 minutes in), when Dennis first locks Burns into his room:

… though as soon as he easily slips outside the window, we breathe a sigh of relief for him. We quickly realize, however, that he is not at all what he seems — or what Dennis believes him to be.

The mystery continues, as we’re introduced to Burns’s sister (Susanne Benton) and her boyfriend (John Garfield, Jr.), and learn why he was out there on that bench during that rainy, cold day.

Suspense continues, and Altman’s confident hand with his camera and actors ensures we are kept engaged — up until the disappointing final five minutes or so. Watch for Michael Murphy in a bit part as a man who helps Dennis procure services in a seedy area of town:

… and Luana Anders — from Dementia 13 (1963) — as a prostitute.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Sandy Dennis as Frances
  • Laszlo Kovacs’ cinematography

Must See?
No, but it’s strongly recommended for one-time viewing. Listed as a Cult Movie in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Camille 2000 (1969)

Camille 2000 (1969)

“Love me now — and let that be enough.”

Synopsis:
A drug-addicted woman (Danièle Gaubert) financially supported by a count (Roberto Bisacco) must confront her priorities when she falls in love with a man (Nino Castelnuovo) who wants to be with her exclusively.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Love Triangle
  • Radley Metzger Films
  • Romance

Review:
Radley Metzger’s follow-up to Therese and Isabelle (1968) was this updated adaptation of Alexandre Dumas fils‘ 1848 novel — a convenient opportunity to wrap a softcore story around an established set of characters and circumstances. Changes include Marguerite (Gaubert) suffering from drug addiction rather than TB, and the entire affair taking place in 1960s swinging Rome:

… but otherwise the inherent melodrama is all there (alongside plenty of explicit sexual encounters). The characters are shallow and the acting is poor, but the sets and costumes are pretty groovy:

… and as always, Metzger uses creative camerawork.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Ennio Guarnieri’s cinematography
  • Good use of location shooting in Rome

Must See?
No; you can definitely skip this one.

Links:

Hour of the Furnaces, The (1968)

Hour of the Furnaces, The (1968)

“Revolutionary violence will put an end to imperialist crimes. Liberation or death!”

Synopsis:
Argentina’s neo-colonialist and revolutionary histories are explored as part of a call for national liberation.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Documentary
  • Revolutionaries
  • South and Central American Films

Review:
Octavio Getino and Fernando Solanas co-directed this four hour and 20 minute political documentary about Argentina, which was shown in extremely limited release in its home country given its incendiary content. It is considered a key entry in the Third Cinema movement (so called as a response to Hollywood films as First Cinema, and European art/auteur films as Second Cinema), and it specifically “rejects the view of cinema as a vehicle for personal expression, seeing the director instead as part of a collective; it appeals to the masses by presenting the truth and inspiring revolutionary activism.”

The Hour of the Furnaces is comprised of diverse historical footage alongside current “stealth” footage and interviews with key players, and is divided into three parts of unequal lengths with intentional time built in for discussion. As one set of title cards tell us:

“This film is a pretext for dialogue, for the search, for different wills to meet. It’s an open report that we offer for your consideration, for you to discuss after the screening is over. The most important thing is to create this unitary space, this dialogue for liberation. Our opinions are as valuable as yours, and you can add to this action any other view or experience.”

In segment one — titled “Neo-Colonialism and Violence” (1 hour and 25 minutes long) — we are informed in all caps:

WE HAVE BEEN TAUGHT A FALSE HISTORY, FALSE HOPES OF WEALTH, A FALSE INTERNATIONAL VIEWPOINT, FALSE ECONOMIC BELIEFS, A FALSE FREEDOM. TO BE FREE, THERE IS ONLY ONE CHOICE: PUT THE PEOPLE IN POWER.

We are given an overview of Argentina’s history of oppression and imperialism by Spain and England:

… and then shown how the hegemonic forces of global capitalism are still at play, with one particularly notable extended sequence intercutting the slaughter of cattle with facile advertisements.


We see and are told that native peoples have been dehumanized (“The Indian was worthless; only a Christian had value”) and are living in poverty:

… while “50% of the land is in the hands of 1.5% of the landowners.”

Segment two (“Act for Liberation”) is the lengthiest at nearly two hours, and includes a more detailed overview of Argentina’s 20th century political history, including Peronism:

… and activist resistance.

Segment three (the shortest at just over 30 minutes) is entitled “Violence and Liberation,” and includes an interview with a political dissident (“Comrade Troxler”) who was tortured and meant to be assassinated but escaped with his life through sheer luck.

We are shown imagery of liberation movements taking place across the globe:

… and reminded that “peaceful coexistence is just opium that permits imperialism.” While this lengthy, history-intensive, no-holds-barred political rejoinder is certainly not for all tastes, it represents a unique moment in cinematic history and will likely be of interest to film fanatics.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Highly effective “guerrilla” filmmaking

Must See?
Yes, for its importance in international cinema.

Categories

  • Historically Relevant

Links:

Lion in Winter, The (1968)

Lion in Winter, The (1968)

“I’ve built an empire — and I must know it’s going to last.”

Synopsis:
In 1183 England, King Henry II (Peter O’Toole) — living with his mistress Alais (Jane Merrow) — summons his imprisoned wife (Katharine Hepburn) back home to his castle, so they can determine who among their living sons — Richard (Anthony Hopkins), Geoffrey (John Castle), or John (Nigel Terry) — will be named as his successor; meanwhile, Merrow’s half-brother Philip II (Timothy Dalton) arrives for a diplomatic visit from France.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Historical Drama
  • Inheritance
  • Katharine Hepburn Films
  • Marital Problems
  • Peter O’Toole Films
  • Play Adaptations
  • Royalty and Nobility

Review:
Katharine Hepburn won her third Best Actress Oscar (sharing it with Barbra Streisand in Funny Girl) for her stand-out performance as Elinor of Aquitane in this adaptation of James Goldman’s play — which, for the record, is not necessarily historical accurate. As a royal drama, however, it plays out beautifully, with Hepburn making a truly majestic entrance by boat:

… and O’Toole – who played a younger version of the same character in Becket (1964) — appropriately larger-than-life from beginning to end. He’s arrogant and emotional, pig-headed yet practical — and it’s easy enough to understand how and why beautiful young Alais (Merrow) loves him and remains loyal.

The entire storyline is about power and succession (topics which remain of enduring interest to current viewing audiences). These particular two narcissistic monarchs equally “love” and loathe their children, despairing over who can or should replace them (no one, naturally; they should live forever) and ultimately shaping their offspring into differently problematic pieces-of-work. Richard’s alleged homosexuality is turned into a significant plot point regarding a dalliance with Philip II (Dalton):

… while “idiotic” John is played for disturbing laughs, openly reviled as a gullible “pustule”:

… and Geoffrey simply seems to be struggling with major Middle Child syndrome. (I can’t really figure out why he wouldn’t be a reasonable option.)

To its credit, given that we know how history turned out, we’re kept on our toes throughout the entire film, wondering what will happen next — and things wrap up in a reasonably satisfying manner. This well-acted historical drama remains worth a look.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Katharine Hepburn as Elinor of Aquitane
  • Peter O’Toole as King Henry
  • Anthony Hopkins as Richard
  • Fine supporting performances by Timothy Dalton, John Castle, and Nigel Terry as Philip, Geoffrey, and John
  • Douglas Slocombe’s cinematography

  • Effectively authentic historical sets
  • John Barry’s score

Must See?
Yes, as a fine film and for the powerhouse performances. Listed as a film with Historical Importance in the back of Peary’s book.

Categories

  • Genuine Classic
  • Noteworthy Performance(s)
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

Links:

Isadora / Loves of Isadora, The (1968)

Isadora / Loves of Isadora, The (1968)

“You’re a legend, aren’t you? A legend in your own lifetime.”

Synopsis:
During the year before her premature death, American dancer Isadora Duncan (Vanessa Redgrave) reflects back on her troubled past, including love affairs with scenic designer Edward Gordon Craig (James Fox), sewing machine heir Paris Singer (Jason Robards, Jr.), and Soviet poet Sergei Yesenin (Zvonimir Crnko).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Biopics
  • Dancers
  • Flashback Films
  • James Fox Films
  • Jason Robards, Jr. Films
  • Karel Reisz Films
  • Strong Females
  • Vanessa Redgrave Films

Review:
Vanessa Redgrave received an Oscar nomination for her role in this biopic of controversial modern dance pioneer Isadora Duncan, whose grisly death by automobile added to her notoriety. Not knowing much at all about Duncan or her innovations to dance prior to watching this film, I began by listening to a two-part podcast episode on her life, which was helpful in laying out the details of her rise from poverty and hustling to provide for her family:

… to her creation of a bohemian, naturalistic dance style (in direct contrast to the constraints of classical ballet):

… to her affairs with Craig (Fox):

… and wealthy Singer (Robards, Jr.):

… both of which led to beloved children.

SPOILER

The tragic deaths of her son and daughter had an enduring impact on Duncan, one from which she understandably never fully recovered. We see her trying to find meaning and purpose in her life after this by following an invitation to the newly emergent Soviet Union:

… where she embarked on an affair with a poet (Crnko) 18 years her junior.

Throughout the film, all of these storylines are intercut as asynchronous flashbacks told by a perceptibly distressed and distraught Duncan, whose life continued on a downward spiral.

We see what brought her the most joy — primarily her work with children:

… though unfortunately there isn’t enough emphasis in the film on this, despite an overly lengthy running time (itself cut down from Reisz’s original vision) which often drags. The overall impression we get of Duncan was that she was a free-spirited, non-conforming, at-times-loopy woman who relentlessly lived according to her own sensibilities; it’s too bad her innovations in dance were ultimately overshadowed by her challenging life and hideous death.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Vanessa Redgrave as Isadora Duncan
  • Larry Pizer’s cinematography

Must See?
No, though it’s worth a look for Redgrave’s performance. Listed as a film with Historical Importance in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Therese and Isabelle (1968)

Therese and Isabelle (1968)

“They’ll never separate us — never!”

Synopsis:
While revisiting the boarding school she attended as a teenager, a woman named Therese (Essy Persson) reflects back on her friendship and romance with Isabelle (Anna Gaël).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Boarding School
  • Lesbianism
  • Radley Metzger Films
  • Sexual Liberation

Review:
This softcore lesbian coming-of-age flick by director Radley Metzger — who later turned to helming adult films under pseudonyms such as “Henry Paris” — features Swedish actress Essy Persson in her best known follow-up to I, a Woman (1966). It’s a terribly written, banal tale of a poor young rich woman (Persson) abandoned at a boarding school by her mother (Barbara Laage):

… who has remarried and no longer has time or attention for her daughter. Persson finds friendship-with-benefits in Gaël, who is more than willing to induct her into sensual realms.

Their lovemaking scenes together primarily consist of their semi-nude bodies while Persson recites hideously prosaic dialogue in voiceover: she informs us that she and Gaël “could find no shelter from the great tide of time;” that Gaël “found [her] as one who finds a fruit;” that she herself “was a violinist stroking the bow.” (There is plenty more of this, albeit much racier and more explicit.) Skip this one unless you happen to be curious.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Hans Jura’s cinematography

Must See?
No.

Links:

Mercenary, The (1968)

Mercenary, The (1968)

“Never question a man who pays well.”

Synopsis:
In early 20th-century Mexico, an emergent revolutionary (Tony Musante) hires a Polish mercenary (Franco Nero) to help him and his female companion (Giovanna Ralli) fight against the government — all while fending off a menacing villain named Curly (Jack Palance).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Jack Palance Films
  • Mexico
  • Revolutionaries
  • Westerns

Review:
Peary only lists one title by Italian director Sergio Corbucci — perhaps best known these days for his influence on Quentin Tarantino — in his GFTFF: this “Zapata western” set during an era of Mexican revolutionary activity. In doing a little more research, I found that not many consider this Corbucci’s top title; that designation would likely go to The Great Silence (1968) — a direct inspiration for Tarantino’s The Hateful Eight (2015) — with Django (1966), given its obvious ties to Tarantino’s Django Unchained (2012), coming next.

With that said, I was glad to be introduced to Corbucci — the “other Sergio,” who also collaborated with Ennio Morricone — through this film; he was quite skilled at crafting both ultra-violent and humorous sequences. Nero and Musante make an effective “odd couple” — at times collaborative, at other times nemeses:

… and Palance rounds things out nicely as a curly-headed ultra-baddie.

(Together, the trio are a clear variation on the “good” [Nero], the bad [Palance], and the “ugly” [Musante].) This flick remains worth a look for fans of spaghetti westerns, but I’ll have to check out a couple of Corbucci’s other titles before deciding which one is must-see.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Creative direction
  • Alejandro Ulloa’s cinematography
  • Ennio Morricone and Bruno Nicolai’s score

Must See?
No, though of course it’s worth a look if you’re a fan of the genre.

Links:

Shame (1968)

Shame (1968)

“What happens when they wake up and feel ashamed of all this?”

Synopsis:
A husband (Max von Sydow) and wife (Liv Ullmann) surviving on an island farm during a civil war find their marriage increasingly strained.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Ingmar Bergman Films
  • Liv Ullmann Films
  • Marital Problems
  • Max von Sydow Films
  • Scandinavian Films
  • Survival

Review:
In this follow-up to Hour of the Wolf (1968), Ingmar Bergman reteamed Max von Sydow and Liv Ullmann as a husband-and-wife duo, this time reflecting feistier dynamics. While these former classical violinists want to simply live a peaceful rural life together:

… they can’t stop quibbling, a situation made even harder given that their lives are repeatedly interrupted by violence from an ongoing civil war, with soldiers and tanks everywhere on the streets.

Made during the height of the Vietnam War, this semi-absurd socio-political film seems to be Bergman’s attempt to comment upon a potential dystopian near-future. As noted in Michael Sragow’s essay for the Criterion Collection:

“As the sixties neared their end, even Bergman, the screen’s foremost investigator of private life, intimate behavior, and post-religious faith, felt the need to make a statement on that turbulent decade and the legacy of World War II.”

To that end, while Sweden infamously took a neutral stance during World War II, things are far from impartial in this film; the island is in a perpetual state of disarray and disruption:

… and the couple literally can’t find anywhere to rest or stay safe. The main narrative arc shows von Sydow becoming more determined than ever simply to survive at any cost; while Ullmann hates seeing his increasing brutality, she also knows she can’t live without him during such uncertain times. This challenging and provocative film isn’t easy to watch, but represents a unique entry in Bergman’s oeuvre and is must-see for fans of his work.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Liv Ullmann as Eva Rosenberg
  • Max von Sydow as Jan Rosenberg
  • Fine location shooting on Fårö island
  • Sven Nykvist’s cinematography

Must See?
Yes. Listed as a film with Historical Importance and a Personal Recommendation in the back of Peary’s book.

Categories

  • Important Director

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links: