Browsed by
Category: Original Reviews

Responses to Peary’s “must see” movie reviews, as well as my own “must see” movie reviews up to and after 1986 (when Peary’s book was published).

Somebody Up There Likes Me (1956)

Somebody Up There Likes Me (1956)

“What’s better: stealing, starving, or fighting?”

Synopsis:
Shortly after a petty criminal (Paul Newman) is sent back to prison for deserting the army, he begins work as a part-time boxer for a promoter (Everett Sloane) and falls for a beautiful young woman (Pier Angeli) who helps him settle down — but can he escape his troubled past when a former associate (Robert Loggia) comes back to ask for a favor?

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Biopics
  • Boxing
  • Ex-Cons
  • Paul Newman Films
  • Pier Angeli Films
  • Robert Wise Films
  • Sal Mineo Films

Review:
Seven years after helming The Set-Up (1949) with Robert Ryan, director Robert Wise made another boxing film — this one based on the story of real-life boxer Rocky Graziano. Paul Newman got a lucky break due to tragic circumstances when James Dean died before shooting began and he took over the lead, which proved to be his breakthrough role. Indeed, Newman is highly convincing as the troubled young man who stumbles into an accidental career in boxing, after learning to survive both his father’s abuse during childhood and a rough life on the streets. Less convincing is his marriage to Angeli, whose interest in Newman despite her abhorrence for fighting of any kind (?!) is insufficiently explored. The cinematography is atmospheric throughout, and the boxing sequences are well-done — but there ultimately isn’t enough to this rise-to-fame story to recommend it as must-see viewing other than for Newman or Angeli fans. Watch for Sal Mineo in a small role as Newman’s teenage buddy, who reappears later in the film.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Paul Newman as Rocky
  • Atmospheric cinematography
  • Well-filmed boxing sequences

Must See?
No, but it’s worth a look for Newman’s breakthrough performance.

Links:

Davy Crockett: King of the Wild Frontier (1955)

Davy Crockett: King of the Wild Frontier (1955)

“Davy Crockett don’t lie.”

Synopsis:
After showing off his mettle by fighting a bear in the wild, frontiersman Davy Crockett (Fess Parker) and his pal George Russel (Buddy Ebsen) play pivotal roles in American history by helping General Andrew Jackson (Basil Ruysdael) battle and then sign a peace treaty with the Muscogee Indians; joining Congress to fight corruption and unfair seizure of Cherokee lands; and helping to defend the Texas Alamo against attacks from Mexican troops.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Fess Parker Films
  • Hans Conried Films
  • Native Americans
  • Westerns

Review:
This compilation of the first few installments of Disney’s five-part television serial about folk legend Davy Crockett offers a fairly seamless adventure tale which is nonetheless clearly divided into three distinct episodes from Crockett’s life: his involvement in the Creek War

his controversial service as a congressman from Tennessee…

and his participation in the Battle of the Alamo.

Parker comes across as appropriately humble, stalwart and brave, and we appreciate his authentic respect for the Native Americans he interacts with.

However, this film likely won’t be of much interest to modern film fanatics given that it was clearly marketed at youth audiences of the day — who responded by kicking off an absolute mania for Davy Crockett paraphernalia, especially coonskin caps.

Fair warning: the title song is guaranteed to remain stuck in your head for hours or days after watching this film (I’m humming it to myself right now…).

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Fine Technicolor cinematography

Must See?
No; you can skip this one unless you’re curious or nostalgic.

Links:

Silver Chalice, The (1954)

Silver Chalice, The (1954)

“A good miracle is only a good trick — unless it is made part of a new religion.”

Synopsis:
A Greek artist (Paul Newman) sold into slavery as a young boy by his adopted uncle (Herbert Rudley) has an ongoing affair with the wife (Virginia Mayo) of a magician (Jack Palance), but grows fond of a young Christian (Pier Angeli) whose grandfather has commissioned him to craft a silver chalice to contain the Holy Grail. Will Newman eventually “see the light” of Christianity — and will Palance effectively convince Emperor Nero (Jacques Aubuchon) that he can fly?

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Ancient Greece and Rome
  • Biblical Stories
  • Christianity
  • E.G. Marshall Films
  • Jack Palance Films
  • Natalie Wood Films
  • Paul Newman Films
  • Pier Angeli Films
  • Virginia Mayo Films

Review:
This notoriously lambasted Biblical epic was considered such a disgrace by emergent star Paul Newman that he purportedly took out ads in Hollywood trade papers proclaiming it the “worst film made in the 1950s”, and enjoining audiences not to watch it. It’s not really all that bad — though it’s easy to see why Newman might want to disown it, especially given that the show really belongs to Jack Palance in a memorably villainous role as a magician who gradually goes mad.

Mayo has received flak for being decked out with outrageously gaudy eye make-up:

and the artistically minimalist sets are criticized as… not realistic enough.


But once one accepts the stylized world on display here, it’s possible to get caught up in the melodrama, which involves Newman eventually meeting the Apostle Peter (Lorne Greene) to add his visage to the chalice.

Angeli is lovely as an innocent young Christian who falls for Newman:

and the scenes set in Nero’s Rome are appropriately surreal — particularly the one in which Nero and his wife are offered platter after platter of gold-plated delicacies with outrageous combinations of edibles.

When Nero (Aubuchon) reminds his wife, “We must not let our people go home in a grumbly mood… We must give them something to watch.”, one can’t help thinking how little has changed in 2000 years vis-a-vis the public’s desire for outrageous spectacles.

Note: Watch for blonde (!) Natalie Wood playing Mayo’s younger self.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Jack Palance as Simon the Magician
  • Pier Angeli as Helena
  • Colorful cinematography and sets

Must See?
No, though it’s worth a look if you’re curious. Listed as a Camp Classic in the back of Peary’s book (which makes sense).

Links:

George Raft Story, The (1961)

George Raft Story, The (1961)

“What’s in it for me?”

Synopsis:
Leaving a life of dancing and criminal involvement behind him, George Raft (Ray Danton) heads from New York to Hollywood, where he eventually makes a name for himself co-starring in Scarface but finds himself typecast far too often as a gangster.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Actors and Actresses
  • Biopics
  • Gangsters
  • Jayne Mansfield Films
  • Neville Brand Films

Review:
This largely fictionalized biopic about George Raft is an odd Hollywood outing, given that Raft was still very much alive when it was made (and Danton looks little like him):

According to one poster on IMDb, “After losing everything he made in Hollywood and after getting [out] with barely a change of clothes from revolutionary Havana in 1959 this man needed a stake. So he sold the story of his life to B studio Allied Artists and the result was The George Raft Story.” Still, one wonders exactly what the point was, other than to highlight Raft’s many criminal connections, and give individuals like Al Capone (Neville Brand):

and Bugsy Siegal (Brad Dexter):

opportunities for “cameo” appearances; other notable individuals in Raft’s life — including Betty Grable, for instance — had to be renamed (in this case, Jayne Mansfield played “Lisa Lang”).

The script gets off to a decidedly odd start, with an extended comedy act in a nightclub (who exactly are those fellows?)

before Raft’s then-girlfriend Sheila (Julie London) sings a ditty:

As the film closes, penniless Raft is given advice to accept roles like Spats Colombo in Some Like it Hot and learn to embrace typecasting because at least it provides a living. Okay.

Note: Check out this interesting article for a blow-by-blow overview of all the films Raft either made or turned down, with an emphasis on the ramifications of the latter.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Effective cinematography

Must See?
No; you can skip this one unless you’re a huge Raft fan and curious.

Links:

Madame Curie (1943)

Madame Curie (1943)

“It’s as though there were a piece of the sun locked up in here!”

Synopsis:
When a Polish science student (Greer Garson) marries an admiring colleague (Walter Pidgeon) in 19th century Paris, the couple — Marie and Pierre Curie — go on to make tremendous strides in their field, including discovering radium.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Biopics
  • Greer Garson Films
  • Margaret O’Brien Films
  • Mervyn LeRoy Films
  • Robert Walker Films
  • Scientists
  • Van Johnson Films
  • Walter Pidgeon Films

Review:
In filming this biopic of Nobel Prize-winning scientist Marie Curie, MGM brought Greer Garson and Walter Pidgeon back together for their fourth of nine on-screen pairings — including, most famously, Mrs. Miniver (1942). They make a fine couple, and it’s surprisingly enjoying watching their lengthy (and most-unusual) “courtship”, with shy Pidgeon ultimately proposing in one of the most amusing such speeches I’ve heard:

“Whereas I’m nervous and impatient – you are quite the opposite. You have a clear mind, you are tenacious, you will never give up. It’s an excellent combination — I might compare it with a chemical formula NaCl, sodium chloride; it’s a stable, necessary compound. So, if we marry on this basis, our marriage would always be the same — the temperature would always be the same, the composition would be the same. There would be no distractions, no fluctuations — none of the uncertainties and emotions of love.”

As scientists intensely committed to their craft, they are quite happy viewing their arrangement as a practical one — though the screenplay eventually shows the depth of love that emerges through their happy and productive union (including the birth of two daughters).

Meanwhile, it’s to the screenplay’s immense credit that lines like, “All right, then — radium won’t be separated from barium.” are authentically interesting (and comprehensible to lay audiences). We watch in eager anticipation as Marie gradually comes to understand (with help from Pierre) the next steps she must take to uncover and isolate radium — then eventually learns about the harm she’s unintentionally caused herself due to so much exposure, but decides it’s worth the risk to continue (albeit with more protections).

The movie is atmospherically filmed throughout (by director Mervyn LeRoy and DP Joseph Ruttenberg), making it a visual treat as well.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Greer Garson as Marie Curie
  • Walter Pidgeon as Pierre Curie
  • Atmospheric cinematography
  • A meticulously told tale of scientific inquiry, rigor, and suspense

Must See?
Yes, as a powerful biopic and for the lead performances.

Categories

  • Noteworthy Performance(s)

Links:

Furies, The (1950)

Furies, The (1950)

“When you know what you want, why waste time?”

Synopsis:
A widowed rancher (Walter Huston) alienates his fiery daughter (Barbara Stanwyck) by marrying a socialite (Judith Anderson) — but Vance (Stanwyck) doesn’t intend to give up her right to “The Furies” ranch so easily, and enlists the help of her lifelong friend (Gilbert Roland) and a local gambler (Wendell Corey) to help her fight back.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Anthony Mann Films
  • Barbara Stanwyck Films
  • Beulah Bondi Films
  • Father and Child
  • Judith Anderson Films
  • Ranchers
  • Revenge
  • Strong Females
  • Walter Huston Films
  • Wendell Corey Films
  • Westerns

Review:
Released the same year as The Devil’s Doorway (1950) and Winchester ’73 (1950), The Furies — based on a novel by Niven Busch — is further evidence of director Anthony Mann’s unique skill with westerns. This psychologically dense tale of familial love and rivalry has an Electra-esque spin:

with Stanwyck clearly coveting a role as her father’s lead partner — to the point of turning violent and vicious once that’s threatened.

In his final role before dying of a heart attack, Huston is a larger-than-life, enigmatic figure, someone whose raw exuberance for ranching is contagious:

… and Stanwyck gives a powerful performance as a woman with intense emotions whose passion for her home (inextricably tied to her her father) ultimately surpasses all other goals in her life.

Three middle-aged actresses — Judith Anderson…

Beulah Bondi (as the wife of an influential banker)…

and Blanche Yurka (as Roland’s mother):

are given memorable supporting roles as well. Meanwhile, the gothic cinematography by Victor Milner is appropriately moody:

providing many haunting shots and moments. This one is well worth a look.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Barbara Stanwyck as Vance
  • Walter Huston as T.C.
  • Fine supporting performances
  • Victor Milner’s cinematography


Must See?
Yes, as an enjoyable classic.

Categories

  • Genuine Classic

Links:

Dark Command (1940)

Dark Command (1940)

“I don’t know much about the law; ain’t had much book learning. But the good Lord gave me a nose for smelling a horse thief a mile off — and what you need in these parts is a marshal that’s better at smelling than spelling.”

Synopsis:
When a Texas cowhand (John Wayne) rides into Kansas with his business partner (Gabby Hayes), he falls instantly in love with a beautiful blonde (Claire Trevor) whose brother (Roy Rogers) is a wannabe cowboy and whose father (Porter Hall) runs the local bank — but soon he is competing with the town’s schoolteacher (Walter Pidgeon) for both Trevor’s love and a job as the town’s marshal.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Claire Trevor Films
  • John Wayne Films
  • Love Triangle
  • Raoul Walsh Films
  • Sheriffs and Marshalls
  • Walter Pidgeon Films
  • Westerns

Review:
Ten years after giving John Wayne his first leading role in The Big Trail (1930), Raoul Walsh once again paired with Wayne for this western loosely based on Quantrill’s Raiders, a pro-Confederate group of guerrilla fighters. Unfortunately, the character arcs presented here — Wayne’s transition from an illiterate strongman who intentionally punches out men’s teeth in order to garner business for his “dentist” partner, and Pidgeon’s transition from a strait-laced schoolteacher to a marauding villain — are too far-fetched to believe, and Trevor’s character is given little to do other than waver between both her would-be beaus. The most notable performance is by Marjorie Main as Pidgeon’s no-nonsense mother, who is for some reason posing undercover as his maid; it’s odd to see her in a completely non-comedic role. Also of note is a graphic sequence involving a wagon with horses tumbling into a river:

As described in TCM’s article:

Easily the most unforgettable moment in Dark Command is an amazing stunt orchestrated by Yakima Canutt. Canutt and several other stunt men slid down a chute into a river forty feet below…along with a wagon and an entire team of horses. It’s an indelible sight for a number of reasons, not the least of which being that the horses were put in great danger for the sake of a piece of celluloid. This stunt, and several others that ended up killing animals in The Charge of the Light Brigade (1936), alerted the ASPCA that major changes needed to take place in the handling of animals while filming motion pictures. Today, any picture that includes animals has an ASPCA member on hand to keep the filmmakers in line.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Fine cinematography
  • Marjorie Main as Mrs. Adams

Must See?
No; this one isn’t must-see. Listed as a Personal Recommendation in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Cattle Queen of Montana (1954)

Cattle Queen of Montana (1954)

“I’m here and I’m going to stay here!”

Synopsis:
After her father (Morris Ankrum) is killed during a Blackfoot raid and their property deed is stolen by a dastardly rival (Gene Evans), an injured cattle rancher (Barbara Stanwyck) remains determined to secure their rightful land in Montana, despite warnings from a hired gunman (Ronald Reagan).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Allan Dwan Films
  • Barbara Stanwyck Films
  • Native Americans
  • Ranchers
  • Ronald Reagen Films
  • Strong Females
  • Westerns

Review:
It’s unclear exactly why Peary lists this Allan Dwan-directed oater in his GFTFF, other than the co-starring of Stanwyck — who is fine (of course) in the title role as a tough gal who won’t be bullied into submission — and then-president Reagan.

A subplot about the rivalry between a rebel named Natchakoa (Anthony Caruso) and a college-educated Blackfoot named Colorados (Lance Fuller):

as well as the jealousy felt by a woman (Yvette Duguay) who has her heart set on Colorados, and believes Stanwyck is in her way:

takes up some time, but basically this is a standard shoot-em-up flick between ranchers-and-Indians, with some pretty hoary dialogue (“When that girl gets an idea, she’s just as stubborn as a mule with a broken hind leg.”). The amount of anti-Indian rhetoric is notable for its blatant racism, and serves as a potent reminder of where we’ve come from:

“A white woman with an Indian? I can’t believe it!”
“There’s only one reason why a white woman takes up with an Indian — and it’s got a mighty nasty name.”
“My nose can’t stand being anywhere near an Indian lover.”

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • John Alton’s cinematography

Must See?
No; you can skip this one unless you’re a Stanwyck fan.

Links:

How the West Was Won (1962)

How the West Was Won (1962)

“The westward course was no smoother than that of true love.”

Synopsis:
Shortly after escaping robbery and death by a river pirate (Walter Brennan) and his clan, a homesteading couple (Karl Malden and Agnes Moorehead) drown in a tragic accident, and their daughters Eve (Carroll Baker) and Lilith (Debbie Reynolds) take different life paths in life: Eve marries and settles down with a mountain man (James Stewart), while Lilith becomes a riverboat singer courted by both an earnest businessman (Robert Preston) and a charming gambler (Gregory Peck). During the Civil War, Eve’s grown son Zeb (George Peppard) and a fellow soldier (Russ Tamblyn) accidentally cross paths with Generals Sherman (John Wayne) and Lee (Henry Morgan). Upon arriving back home, Zeb and a buffalo hunter (Henry Fonda) try to help broker peace with local Native American tribes while a greedy capitalist (Richard Widmark) will stop at nothing to get cross-country railroads built. Finally, while hoping to peacefully settle down with his wife (Carolyn Jones) and kids on land purchased by his widowed Aunt Lilith (Reynolds), Peppard ends up helping a sheriff (Lee J. Cobb) ambush an old enemy (Eli Wallach) plotting a train robbery.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Agnes Moorehead Films
  • Carolyn Jones Films
  • Carroll Baker Films
  • David Brian Films
  • Debbie Reynolds Films
  • Eli Wallach Films
  • Ensemble Cast
  • George Marshall Films
  • George Peppard Films
  • Gregory Peck Films
  • Henry Fonda Films
  • Henry Hathaway Films
  • Jimmy Stewart Films
  • John Ford Films
  • John Wayne Films
  • Karl Malden Films
  • Lee J. Cobb Films
  • Lee Van Cleef Films
  • Richard Widmark Films
  • Robert Preston Films
  • Russ Tamblyn Films
  • Spencer Tracy Films
  • Thelma Ritter Films
  • Walter Brennan Films
  • Westerns

Review:
Divided into five chronologically distinct episodes — The Rivers (1839, d: Henry Hathaway), The Plains (1851, d: Henry Hathaway), The Civil War (1861–1865, d: John Ford), The Railroad (1868, d: George Marshall), and The Outlaws (1889, d: Henry Hathaway) — this sprawling western adventure (narrated by Spencer Tracy) was one of only two narrative films made using the innovative but highly challenging shooting technique of Cinerama (the other was The Wonderful World of the Brothers Grimm [1962]). Surprisingly, there’s a solid continuity to the five vignettes: we feel a sense of investment emerging for the family we’re introduced to in the first episode, as the characters all either age or die off realistically. Reynolds and Baker are appropriately feisty as the lead females whose adventures and/or children ground the stories, and the vast supporting cast of big-name actors are fun to spot in a variety of roles (not all of which could be easily elucidated in the lengthy synopsis above). Meanwhile, the cinematography is truly impressive — especially knowing the lengths to which directors Hathaway, Ford, and Marshall (and their crew of DPs) had to go simply to achieve any given scene (check out Wikipedia’s article for more information).

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Impressive Cinerama cinematography

Must See?
Yes, for its historical significance.

Categories

  • Historically Relevant

Links:

Inherit the Wind (1960)

Inherit the Wind (1960)

“This community is an insult to the world!”

Synopsis:
When a teacher (Dick York) in 1925 small-town Tennessee is put on trial for teaching Darwin’s theory of evolution rather than Creationism, he’s defended by agnostic Henry Drummond (Spencer Tracy), prosecuted by Bible-thumper Matthew Brady (Fredric March), covered in a media spectacle by cynical journalist E.K. Hornbeck (Gene Kelly), and supported by his loving but concerned fiancee (Donna Anderson), whose preacher-father (Claude Akins) is the town’s most vocal opponent of Darwinian theory.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Courtroom Drama
  • Deep South
  • Fredric March Films
  • Gene Kelly Films
  • Lawyers
  • Media Spectacle
  • Play Adaptation
  • Rivalry
  • Small Town America
  • Spencer Tracy Films
  • Stanley Kramer Films

Review:
Director-producer Stanley Kramer helmed this adaptation of Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee’s 1955 Broadway play, based on the infamous Scopes Monkey Trial. Details and names have been changed — see Tim Dirk’s FilmSite review for an extensive analysis — but the essence of the storyline has been retained, while focusing primarily on the drama of two powerful men butting heads on stage (literally so, as shown in this poster). The theme of highly religious citizens defying the incorporation of science and reason into their lives is (sadly) as relevant as ever (it’s odd how pertinent this tale remains nearly 100 years later), as is the notion of the media seizing on a high-emotion battle between two opposing personalities (presidential elections, anyone?). Unfortunately, the fictional inclusion of a conflicted fiancee for York adds unnecessary drama to what was already a powerful enough courtroom tale, and Kelly seems miscast (one expects him to break into song and dance at any moment) — but the film remains worth a one-time look for the noteworthy lead performances and the intrinsic drama of science “versus” faith.

Note: Kramer made a number of “message pictures” right around this time — including The Defiant Ones (1958), On the Beach (1959), Judgment at Nuremberg (1961), and Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner (1968) — and this fits right into that category.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Spencer Tracy as Henry Drummond
  • Fredric March as Matthew Brady
  • Fine cinematography and direction

Must See?
No, but it’s recommended for one-time viewing. Listed as a film with Historical Importance in the back of Peary’s book.

Links: