Browsed by
Category: Original Reviews

Responses to Peary’s “must see” movie reviews, as well as my own “must see” movie reviews up to and after 1986 (when Peary’s book was published).

Guardsman, The (1931)

Guardsman, The (1931)

“It’s a soldier she’s longing for.”

Synopsis:
An actor (Alfred Lunt) who is insanely jealous of his wife (Lynn Fontanne) pretends to be a Russian soldier wooing her, taking only his friend The Critic (Roland Young) into his confidences. Will his wife betray him — with himself?

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Actors and Actresses
  • Jealousy
  • Marital Problems
  • Mistaken or Hidden Identities
  • Play Adaptations
  • Roland Young Films
  • Romantic Comedy
  • Zasu Pitts Films

Review:
Legendary acting couple Alfred Lunt and Lynn Fontanne were both nominated for Academy Awards for their leading roles in this adaptation of Ferenc Molnar’s comedic play about a husband so insanely jealous that he disguises himself as his wife’s suitor to catch her cheating. Does his ruse work? Well, that’s the crux of the somewhat limited storyline, so it wouldn’t be fair to say more; suffice it to say that it’s clear why audiences at the time would have enjoyed a talkie like this, though its current appeal remains simply as a curio, to see this beloved couple on screen together for the first and only time.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Lunt and Fontanne’s obvious chemistry together
  • An enjoyable closing shot

Must See?
No, though it’s worth a look if you’re curious to see Lunt and Fontanne. Listed as a film with Historical Importance in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Lion and the Horse, The (1952)

Lion and the Horse, The (1952)

“I’d of risked my neck to claim that horse for my own.”

Synopsis:
When a cowboy (Steve Cochran) falls in love with a wild stallion he names Wildfire, he hopes to buy the horse but instead is forced to kidnap Wildfire from a cruel rodeo owner (Ray Teal) and hide out on a ranch owned by the avuncular grandfather (R.H. Macy) of a horse-loving girl (Sherry Jackson).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Cowboys
  • Horses
  • Rodeos
  • Westerns

Review:
This kid-friendly western delivers exactly what its title promises: a dramatic showdown between an (escaped) lion and a horse. While these final scenes may be a bit brutal for younger kids, the storyline until then seems perfectly geared towards children who dream of horses. Cochran is given a wonderfully generous role to play, as a man who would do anything to prevent a magnificent creature like Wildfire from abuse and subjugation.

It’s also refreshing to see a girl in the central kid-role (Jackson is likeable and appropriately feisty):

… and there’s a fun musical interlude involving a cowhand learning to play the ukulele by record player:

However, this isn’t must-see viewing for anyone other than Cochran fans, or those who may somehow fondly remember it from their own childhood.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Steve Cochran as Ben Kirby
  • Fine cinematography

Must See?
No. Listed as a Sleeper in the back of Peary’s book, which makes sense. I’m not sure how many people these days know about this title!

Links:

Broken Arrow (1950)

Broken Arrow (1950)

“There can be no peace if there is no good will to try it.”

Synopsis:
Civil War veteran Tom Jeffords (Jimmy Stewart) befriends Apache Chief Cochise (Jeff Chandler) and falls in love with a beautiful young Indian woman (Debra Paget). Can Stewart help broker broader peace between whites and the Apaches, starting with securing safe passage for mail carriers?

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Cross-Cultural Romance
  • Debra Paget Films
  • Delmer Daves Films
  • Jeff Chandler Films
  • Jimmy Stewart Films
  • Native Americans
  • Westerns

Review:
Broken Arrow — scripted by blacklisted writer Albert Maltz, using Michael Blankfort as a front — is notable as one of the first Hollywood westerns to attempt to portray Native Americans in a more balanced and sympathetic light. Despite starring whites (Chandler and Paget) in the lead Apache roles, hundreds of Apaches played extras; much of the action was filmed reasonably close to where the historical events originally took place (in Arizona); and an opening voiceover by Stewart informs us that we will hear the Apaches speaking English simply for the sake of convenience (rather than using the alternative du jour of “broken English”). Indeed, Broken Arrow remains impressive as an early attempt to humanize Indians and show the appeal of their culture to whites like Stewart (at least in his choice of an Indian bride and willingness to live with the tribe). Meanwhile, the storyline is a fairly compelling one — can peace realistically be be brokered when so much ill-will and bloodshed have taken place? — and Ernest Palmer’s Technicolor cinematography is gorgeous.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Jeff Chandler as Cochise
  • Jimmy Stewart as Tom Jeffords
  • Fine location shooting in Arizona
  • A refreshingly nuanced (if inevitably still somewhat inaccurate) portrayal of Apache culture

  • Ernest Palmer’s cinematography

Must See?
Yes, as a compelling and unique western for its era.

Categories

  • Good Show
  • Historically Relevant

Links:

Rush to Judgment (1967)

Rush to Judgment (1967)

“I figure there’s somethin’ else been goin’ on besides what should be.”

Synopsis:
Documentarian Emile De Antonio films lawyer-author Mark Lane speaking with various individuals regarding the veracity of the Warren Commission‘s inquiry into the murder of JFK.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Assassination
  • Documentary
  • Emile De Antonio Films

Review:
Counterculture documentarian Emile de Antonio made a handful of must-see films covering various controversial topics in American history — including Point of Order (1964) about the McCarthy hearings, In the Year of the Pig (1968) about the Vietnam War, and this “alternative view” of the JFK assassination, featuring numerous witnesses whose testimony wasn’t necessarily taken into account when the government crafted its notorious report on the crime. The result is a disturbing insight into how and why conspiracy theories immediately began to circulate, given what seems like clear and ample evidence that complicates the Warren Commission’s findings. Many individuals here seem justifiably distraught — including a man hit by gunfire debris while watching the Dallas motorcycle, a man who witnessed the assassination from a close distance with his five-year-old son next to him, and Abraham Zapruder (who shot the 26.6-second assassination footage seen world-wide), among others. All Americans should make a point of watching this film as part of their overall understanding of what may have happened on the infamous day of November 22, 1963.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Invaluable historical footage




Must See?
Yes, at least for American film fanatics, for its historical relevance.

Categories

  • Historically Relevant

Links:

49th Parallel (1941)

49th Parallel (1941)

“It’s not the Canadian people we’re against; it’s your filthy government.”

Synopsis:
When their U-Boat sinks in Northern Canada, a Nazi naval lieutenant (Eric Portman) and five of his men (including Raymond Lovell and Niall MacGinnis) attempt to make their way across the border to neutral America. During their undercover journey they meet a lusty French-Canadian trapper (Laurence Olivier), a peace-loving Hutterite leader (Anton Walbrook), an art-loving writer (Leslie Howard) living among Indians, and an AWOL Canadian soldier (Raymond Massey).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Anton Wolbrook Films
  • Fugitives
  • Glynis Johns Films
  • Laurence Olivier Films
  • Leslie Howard Films
  • Michael Powell Films
  • Nazis
  • Niall MacGinnis Films
  • Raymond Massey Films
  • World War II

Review:
Just prior to forming their production company The Archers, Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger made this propaganda film specifically to persuade neutral United States to enter the war against Germany (though by the time it was released, they were already involved). Powell and Pressburger’s unique stance is one of making Nazi fugitives the protagonists, meaning we can’t help but somewhat relate to their plight while simultaneously detesting their beliefs and actions. A host of big-name actors lend their heft to snippets of the storyline, beginning with Laurence Olivier sporting a heavy French-Canadian accent as a trapper recently returned from his trade and shocked to find that Canada is at war, and ending with Massey in a heroic turn as an AWOL soldier who does the right thing for his country. Most affecting is the sequence taking place among Hutterites, where MacGinnis is reintroduced to his craft as a baker — and thus remembers what a “good life” really consists of — and Walbrook plays a calm and composed leader. While it’s not must-see viewing, this film remains worth viewing once for its historical interest.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Anton Walbrook as Peter
  • Niall MacGinniss as Vogel
  • Freddie Young’s cinematography

Must See?
No, but it’s certainly worth a look. Listed as a film with Historical Importance in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Jet Pilot (1957)

Jet Pilot (1957)

“General Black, I’m a jet man — not a gigolo!”

Synopsis:
An Air Force colonel (John Wayne) falls in love with a beautiful Soviet pilot (Janet Leigh) who claims she wants to defect, but is actually a spy.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Airplanes and Pilots
  • Cold War
  • Cross-Cultural Romance
  • Hans Conried Films
  • Janet Leigh Films
  • John Wayne Films
  • Josef von Sternberg Films
  • Spies
  • Strong Females

Review:
The origin story of this lackluster Cold War romantic “comedy” — Josef von Sternberg’s final directorial outing — is that Howard Hughes wanted to make a jet-age update to his 1930 film Hell’s Angels, but was so obsessed with getting every detail right that it took seven years from initial filming to release, at which point the jets featured in the film were already outdated.

It’s a fairly ridiculous male fantasy featuring a busty female lead who is Russian but speaks English without any accent at all, and is sexy in all the “right” ways — including loving juicy steaks, beautiful lingerie, and fast planes.

Bosley Crowther was merciless in his review for The New York Times, referring to it as a “dud” that’s “silly and sorry,” and noting that “if it lacks for dramatic vitality, which it most certainly does, you can blame that on a weak script, poor direction and indifferent performances by all.” The one redeeming quality is beautiful cinematography by Winston Hoch, with Leigh looking simply dreamy in all shots.

Peary likely includes this title in his book for its one-time historical notoriety, but it no longer holds that status, and certainly isn’t must-see viewing.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Fine cinematography (primarily of Janet Leigh)

Must See?
No; you can definitely skip this one.

Links:

Dawn Patrol, The (1938)

Dawn Patrol, The (1938)

“You know what this place is? It’s a slaughterhouse – and I’m a butcher.”

Synopsis:
The commanding officer (Basil Rathbone) of an RFC squadron in WWI-era France is replaced by one of his ace pilots (Errol Flynn), who quickly learns how challenging it is to send young men into the air without sufficient training. When Flynn’s best buddy (David Niven) loses his younger brother (Morton Lowry) in a flight, Flynn feels especially responsible, and vows to make things right.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Airplanes and Pilots
  • Barry Fitzgerald Films
  • Basil Rathbone Films
  • David Niven Films
  • Donald Crisp Films
  • Edmund Goulding Films
  • Errol Flynn Films
  • World War I

Review:
Edmund Goulding directed this closely aligned remake of Howard Hawks’ 1930 film of the same name, using stock aerial footage from the previous movie. Thankfully, all the selling points of Hawks’ version are here as well, including powerful performances by the male leads (there were once again no women in the cast) and almost unbearable tension built through cyclical repetition of key themes and motifs — including counting the number of airplane motors heard returning after a mission (to determine how many have died); young replacement recruits arriving just in time to head into the air towards their near-certain death; and alcohol-fueled carousing by the men in order to numb the insanity of their existence. While this film isn’t must-see viewing (I give that status to the original), it remains highly recommended if you can stomach it.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Errol Flynn as Courtney
  • David Niven as Scott
  • Basil Rathbone as Major Brand
  • Tony Gaudio’s cinematography

Must See?
No, but it’s definitely recommended.

Links:

Desperate Journey (1942)

Desperate Journey (1942)

“We must all do our work before we can go back to doing what we love.”

Synopsis:
A group of downed Allied airmen (Errol Flynn, Ronald Reagan, Alan Hale, Arthur Kennedy, and Ronald Sinclair) fight against the Nazis while being pursued by a relentless major (Raymond Massey), eventually receiving support from a beautiful young Resistance fighter (Nancy Coleman).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Alan Hale Films
  • Arthur Kennedy Films
  • Errol Flynn Films
  • Nazis
  • Raoul Walsh Films
  • Raymond Massey Films
  • Ronald Reagan Films
  • World War II

Review:
Raoul Walsh’s second of seven collaborations with Errol Flynn — after They Died With Their Boots On (1941), and before Gentleman Jim (1942) and Objective, Burma! (1945), among others — was this quickly produced comedic wartime drama clearly designed to get young American men excited at the prospect of heading out to war. DVD Savant accurately describes it as “a preposterous tale of Allied derring-do behind enemy lines, with Flynn and his gung-ho buddies (including his Robin Hood sidekick Alan Hale) making fools of the Nazis in their own back yard” — meaning, none of it should be taken too seriously despite the gravity of the subject matter. While several of the airmen do (nobly) die, we know at least some will survive — and to the film’s credit, their final moments are truly a satisfying fantasy.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Bert Glennon’s cinematography

Must See?
No, though Flynn fans will likely want to check it out.

Links:

Man of the West (1958)

Man of the West (1958)

“There’s a point where you either grow up and become a human being, or you rot like that bunch.”

Synopsis:
A reformed outlaw (Gary Cooper) travelling on a hijacked train along with a petty swindler (Arthur O’Connell) and a saloon singer (Julie London) seeks refuge in a cabin inhabited by his former gang mates (Jack Lord, John Dehner, Royal Dano, and Robert Wilke), who are rightfully suspicious about his claim that he’s come back to join them — but their sociopathic leader (Lee J. Cobb) loves Link (Cooper) enough to give him a second chance.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Anthony Mann Films
  • Ex-Cons
  • Gary Cooper Films
  • Lee J. Cobb Films
  • Outlaws
  • Westerns

Response to Peary’s Review:
Peary asserts that this “adult western” about “psychotic killers… who are the total opposites of the romanticized badmen of countless westerns” remains “one of the harshest portraits of the West.” It centers on “a morally ambiguous hero (Gary Cooper) who yields to his long-held-in-check violent nature in order to do in his brutal kin” and contains “a liberal dose of sex, the ingredient that most distinguished it from the spate of television westerns” being made at the time.

He adds that the “shootouts are inevitable and exciting,” and points out that “Cooper is not happy to fight [John] Dehner because he is the man Cooper would have been if he hadn’t deserted Cobb years before.”

He writes that “as in most Mann films, there are two men with similar backgrounds, one who chose to put away his guns as the West became civilized and one who chose to keep being an outlaw, which, in Mann’s films, made his demise inevitable.”

Peary goes on to write that “this picture is also similar to other Mann films because the rugged outdoor landscapes provide the characters with the appropriate environment for uncivilized behavior.”

He points out that “the film’s most notorious, most publicized scene has [Jack] Lord forcing [Julie] London to strip to her underwear” — and, as “an enlightened hero, Cooper realizes London’s humiliation… and gets revenge on Lord later by making him strip while she watches.”

Peary concludes his GFTFF review by noting that this remains “a solid, smart western” with “impressive CinemaScope photography” by Ernest Haller, but he argues that “Cooper shouldn’t be a ‘hick’ in the opening scene.”

Peary elaborates on his thoughts about this film in his first Cult Movies book, where he describes it as a “beautifully filmed, bloody, unsparing western, replete with interesting, complex characters and exciting situations,” and notes that “if it has a major flaw it comes at the beginning,” given that Cooper plays these scenes “as if he were Longfellow Deeds once again.” He adds, “Having [Cooper] come across as being so gullible and innocent that Sam [O’Connell)] and Billie [London] would attempt to wheedle him out of [his] money… is completely deceptive on Mann’s part.”

“If this naive-chump bit were an act by Link to cover up his identity” (which is how I ended up interpreting it) “it would make sense, but it’s for real” (how does Peary know?), and “when we discover that Link used to be a hardened criminal, these early scenes come across as ridiculous.” While “Mann might have been trying to get us to believe Link a weakling so we would be pleasantly surprised later in the film when we see him do heroic deeds,” he asserts that the “change here is too drastic.” I would ultimately agree; regardless of Mann’s motivation, the character shift for Cooper isn’t seamless — though it’s easy enough to forget about the earlier scenes once we enter the “tense melodrama” of “the cabin scenes,” which Mann likened to “those in Key Largo (1948).” Unfortunately, less easy to forgive is Cobb’s overly theatrical performance as the psychotic head honcho of the Tobin gang. Not helping matters any is the fact that 57-year-old Cooper was 10 years older than 47-year-old Cobb in real life, despite playing his adopted son.

However, there’s enough to recommend in this dark western by master-director Mann to make it worthy as once-must viewing.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Gary Cooper as Link Jones
  • Julie London as Billie Ellis
  • Excellent use of outdoor locales
  • Ernest Haller’s cinematography


Must See?
Yes, as a fine western by a master director.

Categories

  • Genuine Classic
  • Important Director

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Seven Days to Noon (1950)

Seven Days to Noon (1950)

Welcome, CMBA members! I’m happy to be participating in the Classic Movie Blog Association’s “Hidden Classics” blogathon. If you’re new to my site, please click here to read more.

For my entry in this blogathon, I chose to re-post my review of a film I discovered with pure delight last summer: John and Ray Boulting’s Seven Days to Noon (1950). This tense, well-scripted movie about a justifiably unhinged scientist threatening to destroy London unless politicians halt all production of Weapons of Mass Destruction remains as potent today as it must surely have been during the Cold War. It’s well worth a look on numerous levels, including atmospheric cinematography and impressive use of on-location shooting across London. I’m puzzled as to why it’s not more widely known and appreciated. I hope you enjoy my review and the film itself! – Sylvia (FilmFanatic)

P.S. If you’d like to post a comment, please send me an email at filmfanatic.org@gmail.com and I will create an account for you.

“What would you do if you were convinced the results of your life work were being put to an evil purpose?”

Synopsis:
A British scientist (Barry Jones) deeply distressed that the world seems unaware of the danger of nuclear bombs sends a note to the Prime Minister (Ronald Adam) threatening to annihilate London unless Adam calls a halt to all production of WMDs. A detective (André Morell) immediately begins to search for Professor Willingdon (Jones), whose assistant (Hugh Cross) and grown daughter (Sheila Manahan) are perplexed and distressed by this turn of events; meanwhile, Jones makes his way across London, seeking refuge and support in unexpected spaces.

Genres:

  • Detectives and Private Eyes
  • Mad Doctors and Scientists
  • Mental Breakdown
  • Nuclear Threat
  • Search

Review:
British filmmakers and identical twins John and Ray Boulting were primarily known for a string of comedies they directed and/or produced in the 1950s and 1960s; a few of their titles are listed in Peary’s book: The Magic Box (1951), I’m All Right Jack (1959), and Cry of the Penguins (1971). This atmospheric Cold war thriller is a pleasant surprise in their oeuvre, and likely their best film, given what a powerful punch it continues to pack. As noted by Bosley Crowther in his review for the New York Times, it’s a “terminally overwhelming picture” filled with “superb pictorial clarity and ever-tightening dramatic suspense”.

From its opening moments until its almost unspeakably tension-filled finale, we’re held on the edge of our seats during this film, feeling anxiety, dread, and a surprising amount of sympathy for the man (clearly unhinged — can you blame him?) about to annihilate one of the world’s largest cities. Fine attention is paid to small details and ambiance throughout the movie, including effective supporting characters (both speaking and silent) and use of authentic locations and extras. Gilbert Taylor’s atmospheric cinematography perfectly captures both the broad scope of a city at risk, as well as the shadowy underworld Jones is pulled into. Most definitely check this one out.

Note: It’s fascinating to read that both Boulting twins married numerous times (John four times, Ray five) and had a total of 13 kids between them (!). They were busy.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Fine performances by the entire cast

  • Atmospheric cinematography by Gilbert Taylor


  • Excellent use of authentic locations and extras


  • The Academy Award-winning screenplay

Must See?
Yes, as a powerful Cold War-era thriller.

Categories

  • Good Show

Links: