Birch Interval (1976)

Birch Interval (1976)

“Something that’s measured is never lost — you know that, don’t you?”

Synopsis:
A fatherless girl named Jesse (Susan McClung) goes to live with her cousins in Pennsylvania Amish country, and learns that the local townsfolk believe her beloved uncle (Rip Torn) is mentally disturbed.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Coming of Age
  • Eddie Albert Films
  • Mental Illness
  • Rip Torn Films
  • Small Town America

Review:
Birch Interval (the film’s odd title is never explained) received scathing reviews from the New York Times upon its release, with director Delbert Mann lambasted for wallowing in “excess, self-indulgence and bathos”, and the film as a whole labeled “what the word ‘icky’ has been waiting for all its life.” These criticisms are ultimately far too harsh, however: while it does dip into a made-for-TV sensibility at times, and the overall arc of the narrative flits around rather unevenly to various vignettes (a local “witch”, a near-rape) without giving them their due, Mann’s overall intention — telling a coming-of-age story, with all its inevitable stickiness and melodrama — remains a worthy one. Especially enjoyable are Rip Torn and Eddie Albert, who turn in fine performances as Jesse’s disturbed uncle and concerned great-uncle respectively; and Mann’s nearly ethnographic filming of the local Amish community (particularly a church session), which was likely fascinating for audiences at the time.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Rip Torn as Jesse’s Uncle Thomas
  • Eddie Albert as “Pa”
  • A documentary-like glimpse at a Pennsylvania Amish community

Must See?
No, but fans of coming-of-age tales will likely be curious to check it out. Listed as a Sleeper in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Manhattan (1979)

Manhattan (1979)

“Chapter one: He was as tough and romantic as the city he loved.”

Synopsis:
A divorced writer (Woody Allen) dating a mature high schooler (Mariel Hemingway) finds himself smitten by the pseudo-pretentious lover (Diane Keaton) of his married best friend (Michael Murphy).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Diane Keaton Films
  • Infidelity
  • May-December Romance
  • Meryl Streep Films
  • Michael Murphy Films
  • New York City
  • Romantic Comedy
  • Woody Allen Films

Response to Peary’s Review:
Peary admits that Manhattan — which he labels “perceptive, witty, [and] masterful” — is his “favorite Woody Allen film”; while I can’t quite agree, there’s no mistaking its status as one of Allen’s finest explorations of New Yorkers’ “insecurities, phobias, [and] quirkiness”. Reviewers at the time (including Peary) were clearly impressed by evidence of Allen’s “growing maturity… as a filmmaker”, with Peary himself noting that Allen finally allows his alter-ego character to be “mean to someone”, “unfair”, and “not the victim”. Ironically, however, this brutal honesty is exactly what makes Manhattan somewhat unpleasant to watch, given that we can clearly see the mistake Isaac (Allen) is making in breaking up with his “sweet, mature” girlfriend (Mariel Hemingway) who “loves him dearly” — if, that is, we’ve gotten over our initial discomfort at their enormous age discrepancy (and stopped wondering why Hemingway’s parents never appear on the scene to have a say in the matter). Diane Keaton is perfectly cast as the elusive object of Allen’s affections, but unlike in Annie Hall (1977), her character here is ultimately too annoying to enjoy.

My favorite scenes — other than those which simply showcase Gordon Willis’ gorgeous shots of Manhattan — are those in which Allen interacts with his ex-wife, Meryl Streep, whose hyper-kinetic movement (she never stays still) reveals her intense discomfort at being around Allen even for a few minutes.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • A truly heartfelt homage to New York City
  • Mariel Hemingway as Tracy
  • Meryl Streep as Allen’s bitter ex-wife
  • Gordon Willis’s stunning cinematography
  • The lyrical Gershwin score

Must See?
Yes, as one of Allen’s early masterpieces.

Categories

  • Important Director

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Psycho (1960)

Psycho (1960)

“She just goes a little mad sometimes — we all go a little mad sometimes.”

Synopsis:
A secretary (Janet Leigh) on the lam with $40,000 of her boss’s money stops at a motel on her way to see her fiance (John Gavin), and becomes acquainted with the motel’s shy, twitchy owner, Norman Bates (Anthony Perkins). When she’s brutally murdered in the shower by Norman’s elderly mother, Leigh’s fiance, sister (Vera Miles), and a private detective (Martin Balsam) all show up at the Bates Motel to investigate her mysterious disappearance.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Amateur Sleuths
  • Anthony Perkins Films
  • Evil Mothers
  • Fugitives
  • Grown Children
  • Horror
  • Janet Leigh Films
  • John McIntire Films
  • Martin Balsam Films
  • Mysterious Disappearance
  • Search

Response to Peary’s Review:
Peary labels this classic Hitchcockian thriller a “manipulative sex and horror masterpiece”, calling it “far and away the most frightening film ever made” — but he notes with a sad caveat that today’s audiences “usually aren’t scared at all.” Indeed, certain elements of Psycho have been so often mimicked and/or over-analyzed that it’s difficult to truly appreciate the impact the film must have had upon 1960 viewers, who were unfamiliar with either the film’s blatant McGuffins (Leigh doesn’t remain the protagonist for long) or the shocking identity twist at the end. Regardless, today’s film fanatics can still watch and appreciate the masterful techniques used by Hitchcock, who consistently foils our expectations and keep us on the edge of our seats — and not just during the infamous “shower scene”.

Anthony Perkins — who, for better or for worse, remained inextricably linked to his “Norman Bates” identity throughout the remainder of his life — gives the most impressive, carefully nuanced performance in the film. He was intentionally cast against type (in the original novel, Norman is middle-aged, pudgy, and balding) to heighten the sexual tension felt between Norman and Marion (Leigh), and to make him more sympathetic to viewers — an essential move, given that Marion’s unexpected death leaves us suddenly having to “relate” to Norman instead. Leigh and Vera Miles are well-cast as the similar-looking Crane sisters (one tragically doomed, the other tenaciously persistent), while Martin Balsam makes an effective private eye. Perhaps the most audacious “character” in the film, however, is Bernard Herrmann’s screeching, all-strings score — it’s nearly impossible to separate this infamous music from the film as a whole.

Note: The blatant sexual undertones Hitchcock and screenwriter Joseph Stefano incorporate throughout the film are truly ahead of their time: from the very first scene — in which busty, unmarried Janet Leigh lies post-coitally on a motel bed in a form-fitting bra and slip — to the nude “shower scene”, to Norman’s obvious sexual perversions, we’re both titillated and disturbed.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Anthony Perkins as Norman Bates
  • Janet Leigh as Marion Crane
  • Vera Miles as Marion’s concerned sister, Lylah
  • Martin Balsam as a no-nonsense private eye
  • The infamous, oft-studied “shower scene”
  • Many truly frightening thrills and chills
  • John Russell’s b&w cinematography
  • Saul Bass’s opening titles
  • Joseph Stefano’s clever, literate adaptation of Robert Bloch’s novel
  • Bernard Herrmann’s instantly recognizable, all-strings score

Must See?
Definitely — this one should be at the top of any film fanatic’s must-see list. Discussed at length in Peary’s Cult Movies 3 (1988).

Categories

  • Cult Movie
  • Genuine Classic
  • Important Director
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Wolf Man, The (1941)

Wolf Man, The (1941)

“Even a man who is pure in heart and says his prayers by night may become a wolf when the wolfbane blooms and the autumn moon is bright.”

Synopsis:
Upon returning to his ancestral home in Wales, the estranged son (Lon Chaney, Jr.) of a local nobleman (Claude Rains) visits a gypsy camp with a beautiful young woman (Evelyn Ankers) and her friend Jenny (Fay Helm). When Jenny is attacked by a wolf, Chaney comes to her rescue and is bitten; soon he starts to suspect that he may have been bitten by a werewolf, and fears that he will begin harming others.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Bela Lugosi Films
  • Claude Rains Films
  • Horror
  • Lon Chaney, Jr. Films
  • Ralph Bellamy Films
  • Warren William Films
  • Werewolves

Response to Peary’s Review:
Peary heaps enormous praise upon this beloved Universal horror flick, referring to it as both “intelligent” and “literate”, and noting that it provides an effective variation on not only the “within-every-man-there-is-a-beast” theme, but also that of the “familiar forties doomed hero — an innocent man who suddenly finds himself trapped and tortured by Fate.” Indeed, while Chaney is no great actor, he’s perfectly cast here as a prodigal son misfit who stands out — both literally and figuratively — as different and strange in his own hometown: hulking Chaney and diminutive Rains make for an extremely unlikely father/son pairing, and Chaney’s broad American accent is in stark contrast to that of the townsfolk. It’s no wonder he quickly finds himself subsumed into the tragic fate of traveling gypsies (also “strangers” in the town).

Although Peary finds Jack Pierce’s makeup “convincing” and the transformation scenes “effective”, most today would disagree; particularly egregious (and puzzling even to Peary) is why Chaney “retains his human form and walks on two furry feet, while [Bela] Lugosi” (the original werewolf; his role is miniscule) “was a full-fledged wolf.” With that said, The Wolf Man relies on atmospheric sets and internal tension rather than make-up and fancy special effects to provide its chills — and in this sense, it succeeds. Of special note is Maria Ouspenskaya in perhaps her most iconic role, as the gypsy woman who informs Chaney what has happened to him; her gentle, maternal chants (“The way you walked was thorny, through no fault of your own”) elevate the film to a higher level altogether.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Effectively atmospheric, fog-drenched sets
  • Maria Ouspenskaya as a wise gypsy woman who takes Chaney under her wing

Must See?
Yes, for its importance in horror film history.

Categories

  • Historically Relevant

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Crossover Dreams (1985)

Crossover Dreams (1985)

“I wanna get outta here… I’m gonna get outta here!”

Synopsis:
An aspiring salsa musician (Ruben Blades) in New York’s Spanish Harlem “crosses over” into mainstream music, only to find that he’s unwisely left behind everyone most important to him — including his loving girlfriend (Elizabeth Pena) and longtime musical partner (Shawn Elliott).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Latinos
  • Musicians
  • New York City
  • Rise-and-Fall

Response to Peary’s Review:
Peary’s review of director Leon Ichaso’s second indie film (his debut was 1979’s El Super) is spot-on: he notes that it “starts out nicely”, offering “original, quirky characters” and plenty of “wit and spirit”, but soon “turns into an unconvincing morality play full of situations and characters we’ve seen in countless other pictures”. Although real-life Panamanian singer Blades is an impressive, believable actor with estimable musical skills, we quickly lose our sympathy for him — and by the second half of the film, he’s no longer even performing on-screen. With that said, there are enough positive elements in Crossover Dreams to make it worth a look at least once, including good use of Spanish Harlem locales, a pulsating salsa soundtrack, and fine supporting performances; it’s too bad the cliched screenplay fails to offer these characters the type of nuanced story they deserve.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Ruben Blades as Rudy Veloz
  • Tom Signorelli in a bit part as a music agent/drug dealer
  • Effective use of authentic Spanish Harlem locales
  • A fabulous salsa soundtrack

Must See?
No, but it’s recommended for one-time viewing.

Links:

Kwaidan (1964)

Kwaidan (1964)

“I saw very clearly the weird woman who killed old Mosaku; I’ve never seen in my life a woman as beautiful and white as her — except you.”

Synopsis:
Four Japanese ghost stories — “Black Hair”, “The Woman in the Snow”, “Hoichi the Earless”, and “In a Cup of Tea” — showcase the importance of loyalty, honor, and fidelity.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Episodic Films
  • Fantasy
  • Ghosts
  • Japanese Films

Review:
This most unusual Japanese horror import — directed by former art student Masaki Kobayashi, and based on a quartet of stories by Greek expatriate Lafcadio Hearn — is an unabashed aesthetic treat. Featuring other-worldly set designs and highly stylized, color-drenched cinematography, it immediately evokes a fable-like sensibility, transporting viewers to an alternate fairy-tale universe where morals are everything and one false step can result in eternal tragedy. To that end, the “horror” element of Kwaidan is systemic rather than explicit: while there is some violence — one character has his ears sliced off in retribution — it’s never gratuitous. Ghosts appear as a matter of course, showing up simply to remind characters that the past is still very much alive, and that spirits are inevitably a part of current existence.

Like most omnibus collections, certain stories in Kwaidan (the title translates roughly into “ghost story”) emerge as more successful than others. The first two episodes — “Black Hair” and “The Woman in the Snow” — are the shortest and most unassuming of the quartet, telling simple yet profound tales of husbands who in one way or another fail to live up to their marital duties; it’s especially gratifying to see the familiar face of Japanese cinema icon Tatsuya Nakadai in the latter. “Hoichi the Earless” is the most flamboyant and central tale of the film, spanning literally centuries: it opens with a stunningly stylized recreation of a samurai battle, then shifts to the impact the battle’s forlorn ghosts have upon a well-meaning priest (Katsuo Nakamura) whose life is put in danger — despite his best intentions — simply by “knowing” them; Nakamura’s likable, authentic performance buoys this rather depressing fable. The final episode in the film — “In a Cup of Tea” — remains just as visually evocative as the others, but ultimately fails to engage on any deeper level. Taken together, however, Kwaidan provides a most unusual viewing experience, one which any film fanatic truly interested in witnessing the diversity of expression international cinema has to offer can’t really afford to miss.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Tatsuya Nakadai as the rescued man in “The Woman in the Snow”
  • Katsuo Nakamura as Hoichi
  • The freaky denouement of “Black Hair” — reminiscent of Mizoguchi’s Ugetsu (1953)
  • The opening samurai battle in “Hoichi the Earless”
  • Truly stunning stylized set designs
  • Yoshio Miyajima’s other-worldly cinematography
  • Countless memorable images

Must See?
Yes, as a most unusual foreign gem. Listed as a film with Historical Importance in the back of Peary’s book.

Categories

  • Foreign Gem

Links:

Pickup on South Street (1953)

Pickup on South Street (1953)

“So you’re a Red, who cares? Your money’s as good as anybody else’s.”

Synopsis:
A pickpocket (Richard Widmark) unknowingly lifts government secrets out of the purse of a woman (Jean Peters) whose boyfriend (Richard Kiley) is a Communist spy. When Widmark discovers how valuable his “take” is, he tries to extort money out of both Peters (who has fallen for him) and Kiley; meanwhile, the police try to get Widmark to turn the goods over to them in exchange for leniency.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Cold War
  • Jean Peters Films
  • Richard Widmark Films
  • Sam Fuller Films
  • Spies
  • Thelma Ritter Films
  • Thieves and Criminals

Review:
From its opening scene on a crowded, sweaty New York subway car, Sam Fuller’s Pickup on South Street astonishes viewers with its no-holds-barred glimpse into the seedy lives of stoolies, pickpockets, spies, and the molls who love them. Utilizing extreme close-ups and effectively rapid-fire editing, Fuller immediately establishes a milieu in which risk and sensuality are deeply intertwined, with plenty of violence greasing the wheels of passion. Despite its Cold War setting — and plenty of anti-Commie rhetoric — Pickup is really less about patriotic fervor (a la camp favorite Shack Out on 101, made two years later) than about the shady individuals who find themselves caught up in the hubbub simply because it’s become a part of their underground survival.

Pickup possesses a slew of memorable characters, including Thelma Ritter as “Moe” (an aging stoolie who wants nothing more than to earn money for a decent funeral), Richard Widmark as the cynical centerpiece of the storyline (it’s difficult to imagine the role better cast), and — in perhaps the most surprising coup of all — Jean Peters as Candy, a smitten yet gutsy and gorgeous dame who’s willing to put up with an enormous amount of guff (both verbal and physical) from Widmark in exchange for his reluctant loyalty and love. The actors are filmed to perfection by cinematographer Joe MacDonald, who encases them in a dense noir ambiance so atmospheric it nearly becomes a character in itself. Pickup on South Street ultimately works on enough levels — visually, thematically, and more — to merit multiple enjoyable viewings by film fanatics.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Thelma Ritter as Moe
  • Richard Widmark as Skip McCoy
  • Jean Peters as Candy
  • The opening pickpocket sequence
  • Effective use of close-ups and rapid editing to convey emotional tension
  • Joe MacDonald’s noirish cinematography
  • Countless classic lines:

    “I have to go on making a living so I can die. But even a fancy funeral ain’t worth waiting for if I gotta do business with crumbs like you.”

  • Leigh Harline’s punchy score

Must See?
Yes; this excellent Cold War thriller should be seen and enjoyed by all film fanatics.

Categories

  • Good Show
  • Important Director

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Elephant Man, The (1980)

Elephant Man, The (1980)

“I am not an animal — I am a human being!”

Synopsis:
In Victorian England, Dr. Frederick Treves (Anthony Hopkins) rescues a severely disfigured man (John Hurt) from his abusive carnival “owner” (Freddie Jones), and allows him his first chance at a life of dignity and respect.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Anne Bancroft Films
  • Biopics
  • Carnivals and Circuses
  • Character Arc
  • David Lynch Films
  • Doctors and Nurses
  • Historical Drama
  • John Gielgud Films
  • John Hurt Films
  • Wendy Hiller Films

Review:
Although it’s often considered to be something of an aberration from director David Lynch’s usual oeuvre, this heartbreaking biopic is actually well in alignment with Lynch’s fascination for the disenfranchised and downtrodden. Oscar-nominated John Hurt (who’s completely unrecognizable) plays the title role of Joseph Merrick, a real-life young man who suffered from a rare congenital deformity known as Proteus Syndrome, making him look decidedly freakish and abnormal; and while there’s no denying Hurt’s inestimable skills as an actor, his success here as Merrick is due in no small part to the tremendous efforts of make-up specialist Chris Tucker, who developed an elaborate synthetic “mask” based on a cast of Merrick’s actual head. Anthony Hopkins — equally affecting in a less “showy” role — plays the doctor who at first is merely fascinated with Merrick’s physical condition, but soon comes to realize that an intelligent, sentient being exists underneath the bulbous folds of skin and bone.

Merrick’s transformation from mute “creature” to dignified gentleman — the crux of the film — is truly a wonder to behold; even those who rarely cry at movies (myself included) will find themselves hard pressed not to be moved by this one. Scene after scene — enacted by a crew of exceedingly well-cast supporting actors — prompts a renewed investigation of our own prejudices, as we realize just how important a relatively “normal” appearance is to our acceptance of others as human. My favorite scenes are those between Merrick and a renowned actress (Anne Bancroft) who barely bats an eye upon seeing Merrick for the first time, and remains resolutely dedicated to treating him like the gentle hero he is. Equally touching is the initial scene between Merrick and Dr. Treves’ wife (Hannah Gordon), whose “natural” acceptance of his appearance causes him to break down in sobs of gratitude.

Some (including, I suspect, Peary, who neglects to nominate either Hurt or the film itself in his Alternate Oscars book) find The Elephant Man overly cloying — and there’s no doubt that our heartstrings are strategically tugged throughout the entire film. Indeed, the final portion of the story — in which Merrick is kidnapped back by Jones, and forced to temporarily revert to his former status as a carnival freak — is nearly too much to bear, and shifts the story into undue pathos. Apart from this aberration, however, Merrick’s journey remains a fascinating one to watch, and proves that there’s nothing more uplifting than watching a character transform and transcend his initial limitations.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • John Hurt as Joseph Merrick
  • Anthony Hopkins as Dr. Treves
  • Anne Bancroft as an admiring actress
  • Wendy Hiller as a no-nonsense nurse
  • John Gielgud as Treves’ superior at the hospital
  • Freddie Jones as Merrick’s abusive captor
  • Hannah Gordon as Dr. Treves’ sympathetic wife
  • Chris Tucker’s extraordinary make-up design
  • Freddie Francis’s cinematography
  • Atmospheric period detail
  • Many heart-breaking scenes
  • An effective soundtrack by John Morris

Must See?
Yes, as a “good show” by an important director.

Categories

  • Good Show
  • Important Director
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Swing Time (1936)

Swing Time (1936)

“No one could teach you to dance in a million years.”

Synopsis:
A dancer with a penchant for gambling (Fred Astaire) is challenged by his future father-in-law (Landers Stevens) to earn $25,000 before marrying his daughter (Betty Furness), and heads to New York with his trusty sidekick, “Pop” (Victor Moore) to secure the funds. Once he arrives, however, he falls immediately in love with a young dance instructor (Ginger Rogers), and tries his best not to earn the money; meanwhile, Rogers is pursued by a slick orchestra conductor (Georges Metaxa) who is eager to marry her.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Dancers
  • Fred Astaire Films
  • George Stevens Films
  • Ginger Rogers Films
  • Love Triangle
  • Musicals
  • Romantic Comedy

Response to Peary’s Review:
As Peary notes, “there’s little to complain about” with regards to this “enchanting” Astaire/Rogers collaboration — often cited along with Top Hat as one of their most successful ventures. He points out that, for once, “the stars play real — well, almost real — people”, noting that it’s easy to root for them given that they’re playing such “appealing, unpretentious characters”. Unfortunately, the script gets off to a rather painful start, with no dancing for the first half hour, and a truly cruel — albeit ultimately “for the best” — practical joke played upon poor Astaire, who’s made to miss his own wedding. Once he arrives in New York and meets Ginger, however, the sparks begin to fly, with song after song a true delight. The script somewhat predictably revolves upon mistaken identities (Rogers doesn’t know that Astaire is an engaged man), but this time around the storyline remains relatively believable, and eminently affecting.

Rogers — perhaps due to expert guidance from director George Stevens — is in peak form, investing her character with pathos and genuine charm; Astaire is equally fine, and it’s fun to see both Eric Blore and Helen Broderick returning in supporting roles (though Blore’s part should have been bigger). It’s amazing to note that the New York Times reviewer of the day (Frank Nugent — evidently tone deaf) dismissed Jerome Kern’s score as “merely adequate, or worse” — he actually complained about not being able to “whistle a bar” of any of the tunes upon leaving the theater! Personally, I can’t get “A Fine Romance” out of my head for the life of me…

Note: The series’ signature art deco set designs are still evident, though toned down considerably to suit the working-class characters’ lifestyles.

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Fred and Ginger’s first thrilling dance together, “Pick Yourself Up”
  • Fred singing “The Way You Look Tonight” to Ginger while her hair is full of shampoo (actually whipped cream)
  • Ginger and Fred dancing the classy “Waltz in Swing Time”
  • Ginger and Fred singing “A Fine Romance” back and forth to each other across the snow
  • Astaire’s Bojangles homage, dancing with the shadows
  • Fred and Ginger’s evocative final dance
  • Classy art deco set designs
  • Ginger Rogers giving perhaps her best performance of the series
  • Jerome Kern’s score — not just his signature songs, but the cleverly orchestrated soundtrack itself

Must See?
Yes, as one of the classic Rogers and Astaire collaborations. Peary nominates it for an Alternate Oscar as best picture of the year.

Categories

  • Genuine Classic
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Top Hat (1935)

Top Hat (1935)

“In dealing with a girl or horse, one just lets nature take its course.”

Synopsis:
Confirmed bachelor Jerry Travers (Fred Astaire) — in London to perform a show, and staying with his wealthy friend Horace (Edward Everett Horton) — finds himself falling head-over-heels in love with a beautiful young model (Ginger Rogers) living in the room below his. Complications ensue when Rogers mistakenly believes Astaire is Horace, the husband of her best friend Madge (Helen Broderick).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Fred Astaire Films
  • Ginger Rogers Films
  • Mistaken or Hidden Identities
  • Musicals
  • Romantic Comedy

Response to Peary’s Review:
As Peary notes, this “exceptional Fred Astaire – Ginger Rogers Depression-escaping musical” features “fabulous dancing, a topflight Irving Berlin score, terrific supporting players… [and] spectacularly stylish Art Deco sets”. It’s widely acknowledged as one of the best of Astaire and Rogers’ collaborations together, and it certainly possesses some of the best-loved songs — most notably “Cheek to Cheek” (that feather dress!) and “Top Hat, White Tie, and Tails”. The “typically preposterous plot” is silly beyond belief but enormous fun once you give in to the cleverly plotted script, which allows the mistaken-identity snafu to go on far longer than would ever be expected. There’s no denying the magic of Astaire and Rogers dancing together (and Astaire dancing alone) — but I’ll admit my favorite aspect of Top Hat is the truly hilarious banter between the supporting character actors — most notably Edward Everett Horton and Eric Blore; their initial domestic quibble over “square versus butterfly ties” is priceless. Watch and enjoy…

Redeeming Qualities and Moments:

  • Fred Astaire as Jerry Travers
  • Ginger Rogers as Dale Tremont
  • Astaire’s opening dance number (set to “No Strings”) in Horton’s apartment
  • Rogers and Astaire dancing “Cheek to Cheek”
  • Astaire wooing Rogers during the “Isn’t It a Lovely Day to Be Caught in the Rain” number
  • Astaire’s stylish “Top Hat and Tails” dance
  • Edward Everett Horton as Horace
  • Eric Blore as Horton’s snobby valet
  • Helen Broderick as Horton’s “understanding” wife, Madge
  • Erik Rhodes as Beddini, the passionate Italian dress designer: “Never again will I allow women to wear my dresses!”
  • Rogers’ gorgeous gowns
  • The marvelously baroque — and oh-so-RKO — art deco set designs
  • Hermes Pan and Astaire’s collaborative choreography
  • The wonderfully unrealistic “mistaken identities” screenplay
  • Irving Berlin’s classic score

Must See?
Yes. This undisputed classic — widely acknowledged as the archetypal Astaire and Rogers collaboration — should be seen and enjoyed by all film fanatics. Discussed at length in Peary’s Cult Movies (1981).

Categories

  • Genuine Classic
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links: