Forbidden Planet (1956)
“The fool, the meddling idiot! As though his ape’s brain could contain the secrets of the Krell!”
Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:
Response to Peary’s Review:
While I’m annoyed by Robby — his interactions with a tippling cook (Earl Holliman) are especially groan-worthy — I actually believe the film’s worst error is its lack of (strong) female characters. Forbidden Planet immediately and unambiguously fails the Bechdel Test, given that there is only one female character (Francis) who is thus unable to talk to another female about anything, let alone a topic other than men. Indeed, nearly all of Francis’s dialogue centers ON men — from her growing understanding of what this “sexual attraction” thing is all about, to which man she will (inevitably) end up attached to, to how she can dress in a way that will make the men more comfortable, etc. She’s ultimately little more than skimpily dressed eye candy.
Of minor interest is the fact that Forbidden Planet‘s storyline is loosely based on Shakespeare’s The Tempest — though we never fully understand why Morbius is so protective of his daughter, given that the “Freudian-incestuous elements are toned down.” Once the narrative centers on Nielsen’s exploration of Altair-IV and his growing understanding of Pidgeon’s history on the planet, however, we immediately become drawn in — thanks in large part to the truly “marvelous design of Altair-IV and the Krell underground chambers”, as well as some nifty special effects. Also wonderfully innovative is the “electronic music by Louis and Bebe Barron”. Regardless of its flaws, film fanatics will likely want to check this one out at least once, given its popularity and historical importance.
Redeeming Qualities and Moments:
(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)
One thought on “Forbidden Planet (1956)”
Must-see, and it seems I have different take on this:
Take one part Shakespeare’s ‘The Tempest’, one part Jungian theory, and about 5 parts total ’50s sci-fi. Mix and stir. For years, the Rocky Horror Picture Show lyrics were reminding me that “Anne Francis stars in…’Forbidden Planet’…”. So I figured it was time to revisit it.
And what a cool movie! One might expect it to be completely quaint now – and, at first, it does look like it will be simply that. But give it time. It has a wonderfully intelligent script. Walter Pidgeon is on-hand for a solid professorial leading role, Ms. Francis is charm personified, and Leslie Nielsen – even though you may keep expecting him to turn into Frank Drebin – is oddly authoritative as the commander.
The root of the story is “the stored knowledge of the Krell” – which is simply amazing stuff. But apparently like all stuff that is not the pure stuff of God – even if it bears a remarkable similarity…it is, unfortunately, tainted (as is everything that is not, as we’re ultimately told, of God). Still, its possibilities are enough of a marvel to boggle the mind.
There is a fair amount of backstory info on this film at Wikipedia, for those interested. For example, when the film was re-released in theaters in 1972, 6 minutes of the film had to be cut (at that time) in order to get a ‘G’ rating (!). But of larger interest…as recently as 7 years ago, talk began on a new film version…which seems to still be in the talking stage, and may stay there without going further. Should ‘Forbidden Planet’ be re-made? Well, we have better technology now for sci-fi films, certainly. Yet part of me says…’Awww…don’t do it. Just leave it as it is.’