Browsed by
Category: Original Reviews

Responses to Peary’s “must see” movie reviews, as well as my own “must see” movie reviews up to and after 1986 (when Peary’s book was published).

Great Rock ‘n Roll Swindle, The (1980)

Great Rock ‘n Roll Swindle, The (1980)

“With the lineup complete, we immediately set about putting our plan into effect, to swindle our way to the top of the rock n roll industry.”

Synopsis:
Sex Pistols manager Malcolm McLaren explains how the former punk rock band’s creation was all a scam to earn money, offering up the ten tips for financial success he followed.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Mockumentaries
  • Punk Rock

Review:
Julien Temple wrote and directed this mockumentary about the rise and fall of the Sex Pistols (already dissolved by the time of the film’s release) according to its managing director, Malcolm McLaren. Johnny Rotten notoriously wanted nothing to do with the film, while the other band members — Sid Vicious, Steve Jones, and Paul Cook — played smaller roles.

Truly nothing is sacred here, as one might expect in a satirical look at such an anarchist form of expression; by the end of the first 10 1/2 minutes, the title card has been assembled by a punk rock midget on skates (Helen Wellington-Lloyd):


… and the pacing never slows after this. We see a wide variety of (often non-sensical) sequences intermingled with the band performing some of their hit songs, including Sid Vicious’s version of “My Way”.

For the record, here are the “10 lessons” espoused by McLaren:

  • 1) “Make the band.” Find four kids who hate each other and can’t actually play.
  • 2) Make the name known, but keep the band out of normal rock venues, instead booking them into strip clubs, prisons and fashionable parties. Put people in the crowd who will cause trouble and keep the press curious, and focus on fans dressing up rather than what the band is actually playing.
  • 3) “How to sell the swindle.” Hire a lawyer who cares about money, get different labels bidding on the band, and be as obstructive as possible.
  • 4) Use outrage to foment hatred and press.
  • 5) “How to steal as much money as quickly as possible from the record company of your choice.” Get dropped fast (using the band’s misbehavior as an excuse) but keep the money.
  • 6) “How to become the world’s greatest tourist attraction.” Latch on to a current event (like the Queen’s Jubilee).
  • 7) “Cultivate hatred, it is your greatest asset.” This can include booking a tour that no one can get to, spreading false rumors, and never letting the press know if the band can actually play.
  • 8) “How to diversity your business.” Four musicians who can’t play are also “four actors that can’t act,” so come up with a film but then make the script too disgusting for anyone to want to produce it.
  • 9) Sign with an American label and play only in backwoods venues.
  • 10) Figure out a way to get out of the “rock ‘n roll circus.”

My favorite sequence: the film crew visit a singing instructor who diplomatically explains how she tried to help Johnny Rotten, to no avail: “But supposing, just supposing, that he took, um, ‘Submission’ and he decided that he — he might sing that, and I’d say ‘Right, now I know where we are.’ And by the time I was ready, he would have changed key. No way, absolutely no way, could we pick up a note.”

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Many bizarrely memorable moments
  • Creative animation sequences

Must See?
No, though it’s worth a look for its cult status.

Links:

Claudine (1974)

Claudine (1974)

“We got a real sweet project going — so let’s be straight.”

Synopsis:
When a working single mother (Diahann Carroll) of six meets a charismatic garbage collector (James Earl Jones) and starts dating him, the couple immediately face issues related to welfare, parenting, and survival.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • African-Americans
  • Romantic Comedy
  • Single Mothers
  • Survival

Review:
Diahann Carroll — perhaps best known for starring in the T.V. show “Julia” (1968-1971) — won an Oscar nomination for her role as the title character in this romantic-comedy which showed audiences a more authentic, albeit still heavily Hollywoodized, vision of Black urban life in the 1970s. It’s impossible not to root for Carroll (a last minute replacement for her good friend Diana Sands) and Jones, whose romance is a sweet if chaotic balm in the midst of Carroll’s hectic life:

… centered on navigating a truly dehumanizing “welfare” system which forces Carroll to make terrible but necessary decisions about her home life.

The location shooting in Harlem is delightful, and surely adds to the nostalgia and appreciation many feel for this film.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Diahann Carroll as Claudine
  • James Earl Jones as Roop
  • Excellent use of location shooting in Harlem

  • A frank, darkly comedic look at the absurdities of the welfare system
  • Curtis Mayfield’s score (performed by Gladys Knight and the Pips)

Must See?
Yes, for Carroll and Jones’ performances. Listed as a Sleeper in the back of Peary’s book.

Categories

  • Noteworthy Performance(s)
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

Links:

Absolute Beginners (1986)

Absolute Beginners (1986)

“We don’t sell things – we sell dreams.”

Synopsis:
In 1950s Britain, an aspiring photographer (Eddie O’Connell) is distressed when his girlfriend (Patsy Kensit) is wooed away from him by a wealthy dandy (James Fox) — but soon O’Connell himself is caught up in a complex web of fame and violence, including being hired by a racist property developer (David Bowie).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • David Bowie Films
  • James Fox Films
  • Love Triangle
  • Musicals
  • Photographers
  • Racism and Race Relations

Review:
Based on a novel by Colin MacInnes, this wildly expressive musical — directed by Julian Temple, whose other GFTFF title is The Great Rock and Roll Swindle (1980) — was notorious for contributing towards the bankruptcy of Goldcrest film company. Indeed, it never quite took off with audiences, but it’s an unusual enough production to merit viewing — especially given its creative sets and staging (including an impressive single-take opening shot):

… and the casting of David Bowie. (According to IMDb’s Trivia page, “Julien Temple asked David Bowie to write music for the film. After reading the book and then the script, Bowie agreed to Temple’s offer if he could also play the part of Vendice Partners.”)

In his review, DVD Savant questions whether the film is actually “good,” noting regardless that “the movie is eye candy from one end to the other, a parade of color and costume creativity, flashy but not exaggerated editing, and the occasional snappy choreographic scene.” Indeed, it’s literally hard to pull your eyes away from this flick, given that “there are no calm scenes. To express the vitality and urgency of his characters, Temple keeps the camera moving at all times through crowds of eccentric supporting and bit players.”

While there is far too much going on narratively, one can’t accuse Temple or his team of shying away from appropriately controversial topics, ranging from the toxic allure of fame and capitalism to violent systemic racism. To that end, one more trivia item on IMDb offers a useful comparison:

Elements of this film seemingly share a similar genre with West Side Story (1961), most obviously a 1950s period musical set against a background of gangs and knife crime. But, where West Side Story is well-known as a version of Romeo and Juliet, there’s a major element in this film that clearly continues to affect its box office takings, lack of home video releases, and lack of television showings, decades later, is primarily the volume of racist material, unavoidable due to the underlying story, and the “fascists” portrayal, even though its set in the 1950s, which can be taken out of context. Shot as a straight drama, the film may have had a completely different success.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Olive Stapleton’s creative cinematography


  • Vibrant production design, sets, and costumes
  • Many creatively staged sequences

  • A daringly forthright expose of xenophobia and racism in Britain
    Content warning: overt use of the N word
  • David Bowie as Vendice Partners

Must See?
Yes, once, as a most unique film of its era, and for its historical relevance. Listed as a Cult Movie in the back of Peary’s book.

Categories

  • Historically Relevant

Links:

Woman Under the Influence, A (1974)

Woman Under the Influence, A (1974)

“Mabel is not crazy; she’s unusual.”

Synopsis:
When a construction worker (Peter Falk) and father of three finds himself unable to handle the increasingly unconventional behaviors of his wife (Gena Rowlands), he wonders about next steps to take.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Feminism and Women’s Issues
  • Gena Rowlands Films
  • Housewives
  • John Cassavetes Films
  • Marital Problems
  • Mental Breakdown
  • Peter Falk Films

Review:
Husband-and-wife-team John Cassavetes and Gena Rowlands’ fourth collaboration was this Oscar-nominated (for Best Director and Best Actress) neo-realistic classic accurately described by DVD Savant as “fascinating, exhausting and highly rewarding.” Indeed, the film (scripted by Cassavetes) is so emotionally exhausting that I put off a revisit for more than 20 years, until my 17-year-old daughter watched it recently in a film class and was super-eager to discuss it with me. Bingo! I had my motivation to re-engage with this heartbreaking portrait of an eccentric, loving, playful, overly-honest woman whose intensities and inability to conform are simply too much for society (and her husband) to handle.

What I was most curious about upon this second viewing — much later in my life, now with three kids of my own — was to get a better sense of what, exactly, Mabel was “under the influence” of: delusions? substances? her husband? society? patriarchy? all of these? (This remains hotly debated; check out Reddit for robust discussions.) In the opening scene, while dealing with disappointment that her husband Nick (Falk) can’t make it home for a specially planned evening together, she acts out through drinking and dallying.

At this point, we feel sorry for hardworking Nick, who’s stuck in a laborious overnight shift and dreads disappointing his wife. However, when he proceeds to bring home his entire crew the following morning for socializing — rather than returning alone, apologizing, and doing what he can to make things up to Mabel — we begin to see that his coping responses aren’t exactly healthy, either.

Adding to Mabel’s stress is Nick’s overbearing mother (played by Cassavetes’ real-life mom, Katherine Cassavetes), who doesn’t hesitate to share her true feelings: “[My son] says you give him nothing! You’re empty inside! Your children are naked! They’re hungry!”

Also part of Mabel’s living nightmare is the presence of a seemingly kind but insistent doctor (Eddie Shaw) determined to shoot her up with sedatives and take her away from her beloved kids.

Meanwhile, we’re also given stronger indications of Nick’s racism and short temper, particularly during a harrowing work-site scene depicting his Mexican colleague tumbling down a ledge after Nick yells at him.

Is Nick a MAN “under the influence” as well? Yes, he clearly is — but, as a (white) male, he also gets to make the decisions in his spheres of influence: he drags his kids to the beach for a requisite family outing, not only failing to have a fun time with them, but giving his boys beer in the back of a truck on their way home.

The final harrowing scenes take place six months later, back at Nick and Mabel’s home (filmed in “a slightly run-down house on Taft Avenue, just off Hollywood Boulevard”), where Nick has inexplicably invited seemingly everyone he knows (and then some) over in anticipation of celebrating Mabel’s arrival back from her enforced hospitalization.

In truth, Nick doesn’t actually WANT to be left alone with his wife — despite the fact that this (and being with her kids) is all she wants after being gone for so long. Meanwhile, Nick repeatedly implores her to “Just be yourself — be yourself!”, yet doing just that is precisely what got her put away. Talk about a double-bind. Mabel pleads with her clueless father (Fred Draper) to “just stand up” for her, but he literally has no idea what she means by this, and is thus yet another unreliable male figure in her life. (My daughter told me this was the most heartbreaking scene of all for her.)

In the film’s final unnerving moments, Nick and Mabel are co-habitating once again in their mostly empty house, but can’t stop moving, working, cleaning… Will they be able to repair things? At the very least (as Falk pointed out in a later interview reflecting back on the film), his character doesn’t pick up the phone while it’s ringing — thus presumably ignoring his mom, for awhile. It’s a start.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Gena Rowlands as Mabel
  • Peter Falk as Nick
  • Fine cinematography
  • Excellent use of natural locations

Must See?
Yes, as a memorable neo-realist classic.

Categories

  • Important Director
  • Noteworthy Performance(s)
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

Listed as a Cult Movie and a Personal Recommendation in the back of Peary’s book.

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Duck, You Sucker! / Fistful of Dynamite, A (1971)

Duck, You Sucker! / Fistful of Dynamite, A (1971)

“If I fall, they’ll have to alter all the maps.”

Synopsis:
When an Irish revolutionary (James Coburn) meets up with a Mexican bandit (Rod Steiger) during the time of Zapata and Pancho Villa, a complicated collaboration ensues.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Cat and Mouse
  • James Coburn Films
  • Mexico
  • Revolutionaries
  • Rod Steiger Films
  • Sergio Leone Films
  • Thieves and Criminals
  • Westerns

Review:
Sergio Leone’s follow-up to Once Upon a Time in the West (1968) — his sixth and penultimate film before Once Upon a Time in America (1984) — was this rambling operatic western about betrayal, values, explosives, and (marginally) revolution in early 20th century Mexico. At the heart of the narrative is the cat-and-mouse turned shakily-collaborative alliance between Coburn and Steiger, whose initial meeting on the road fills the enjoyable first half-hour of the film.

After this, we learn a bit more about Coburn’s previous involvement in the IRA and a love triangle through intentionally slow-paced (occasionally slo-mo) flash-back sequences:

… and we see how Steiger and Coburn (playing characters named “Juan” and “Sean” respectively — both variations on “John”) come to realize their mutual respect for one another. Everything is beautifully filmed, with strategic framing, excellent use made of extras and expansive sets, an instantly jaunty score by Ennio Morricone, and many effectively set up scenes of explosions.

However, be forewarned that the storyline — intended to deglamorize revolution and reveal it as the violent, chaotic, corrupt mess it is (the film’s working title was Once Upon a Time… The Revolution) — goes on for too long and is challenging to follow at times. Leone fans won’t want to miss this one, but it’s not must-see for other film fanatics.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • James Coburn as John (Sean) Mallory
  • Rod Steiger as Juan Miranda
  • Coburn and Steiger’s entertaining banter with one another
  • Giuseppe Ruzzolini’s cinematography
  • Masterful direction of both close-up and wide panning shots

  • Impressive sets and costumes
  • Ennio Morricone’s score

Must See?
No, but it’s recommended for fans of Leone. Listed as a Cult Movie and a Personal Recommendation in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Blindman (1971)

Blindman (1971)

“I didn’t see a thing.”

Synopsis:
When a blind gunslinger (Tony Anthony) hired to bring 50 mail-order brides to miners in Texas learns that his business partner Skunk (Ringo Starr) has double-crossed him by selling the women to a bandit (Lloyd Batista), he travels to Mexico determined to complete his mission at any cost.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Blindness
  • Cat and Mouse
  • Ringo Starr Films
  • Westerns

Review:
Ferdinando Baldi’s Spaghetti-western homage to Zatoichi the Blind Swordsman developed cult status in part due to the presence of Ringo Starr in a co-leading role.

Anthony — best known for The Stranger Spaghetti-western-series (which I haven’t seen) — wore intensely painful contact lenses (he wouldn’t do a sequel) to embody a blind man on a last-chance mission to secure a comfortable life through a hefty pay-out.

The entire story consists of a cat-and-mouse attempts to transport objectified beauties from one set of aggressive, dirty men to another, with plenty of exploitation scenes thrown in — just, because. As DVD Savant, a fan of this film, puts it:

… parts of this show veer close to Seventies’-style exploitation cinema too. There’s nudity present in a few sequences here, most notably the sequence where the mail order brides are forced to wash before the arrival of the visiting Federales. But if this is exploitation cinema, it’s exploitation cinema as Sergio Leone might have shot it.

Personally, I grew tired of explosions and violence long before this film’s (restored) 105 minutes were over — but at least the cinematography and sets are appealing.

Notable Performances, Qualities, \and Moments:

  • Riccardo Pallottini’s cinematography

Must See?
No; skip this one unless you’re a diehard Spaghetti Western fan or a Starr groupie. Listed as a Cult Movie in the back of Peary’s book.

Links:

Permanent Vacation (1980)

Permanent Vacation (1980)

“It’s better to think that you’re not alone when, you know, you’re drifting — even though you are.”

Synopsis:
An aimless young man (Chris Parker) with an institutionalized mother (Ruth Bolton) says goodbye to his girlfriend (Leila Gastil) and wanders the streets of New York, encountering a variety of diverse individuals while contemplating his life.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Jim Jarmusch Films
  • Misfits
  • New York City

Review:
Jim Jarmusch’s feature debut was this 75-minute cinema verité film made on a budget of just $12K. Courtesy of Wikipedia, here is some background on how it came to be:

In his final year at New York University, Jarmusch worked as an assistant to the film noir director Nicholas Ray, who was at that time teaching in the department. In an anecdote, Jarmusch recounted the formative experience of showing his mentor his first script; Ray disapproved of its lack of action, to which Jarmusch responded after meditating on the critique by reworking the script to be even less eventful. On Jarmusch’s return with the revised script, Ray reacted favourably to his student’s dissent, citing approvingly the young student’s obstinate independence. Jarmusch was the only person Ray brought to work — as his personal assistant — on Lightning Over Water, a documentary about his dying years on which he was collaborating with Wim Wenders. Ray died in 1979 after a long fight with cancer. A few days afterwards, having been encouraged by Ray and New York underground filmmaker Amos Poe and using scholarship funds given by the Louis B. Mayer Foundation to pay for his school tuition, Jarmusch started work on a film for his final project. The university was unimpressed with Jarmusch’s use of his funding as well as the project itself and refused to award him a degree.

That final project was Permanent Vacation — and this helpful overview clarifies why Jarmusch chooses to have his protagonist stop by a screening of one of Ray’s films, The Savage Innocents (1960):

… though the man he’s seated next to in the lobby (Frankie Faison) is actually discussing the Doppler Effect, not the movie.

At any rate, to round out this review, I’ll go ahead and describe a few more things that “happen” in the script, described by Allie (Parker) thusly:

“This is my story — or part of it. I don’t expect it to explain all that much, but what’s a story, anyway, except one of those connect-the-dots drawings that in the end forms a picture of something? That’s really all this is.”

SPOILERS AHEAD

– Allie reads out loud to his girlfriend from the surrealist poetic novel “Maldoror and Poems” (1978) by Lautreamont: “I was not present at the event of which my daughter’s death was the result. If I had been, I would have defended that angel at the cost of my blood.”

– Allie tours the blown-up remains of the home where he was born, encountering a veteran (Richard Boes) while there.

– Allie visits his mother (Bolton) in a mental institution while an older woman (Evelyn Smith) in the nearby bed bursts repeatedly into laughter.

– Allie walks by a crying Latina (Maria Duval) in her slip on a back porch stoop, and can’t understand what she’s saying.

– Allie encounters a saxophonist (John Lurie) who plays a song for him.

– Allie is offended when a young woman (Suzanne Fletcher) asks him to drop her letter in a mailbox, and shows his annoyance by quickly stealing and driving away in her car when she gets out to do so herself.

– Allie sells his “new” car to a Budweiser-drinking dealer for $800.

– Allie encounters a similarly-dressed hipster near a ship bound for Paris:

… and heads off on a cross-Atlantic adventure. The End.

Jarmusch’s next major film was Stranger Than Paradise (1984), beloved by many but not me. Suffice it to say his work is simply not to my tastes. To be fair, however, I certainly remember the days when dialogue like Jarmusch’s felt much more profound and relevant. As Allie puts it:

“I’m just not the kind of person that settles into anything. I don’t think I ever will be. There isn’t really anything left to explain that can be — and that’s what I was trying to explain in the first place, just not like that. I don’t want a job, or a house, or taxes although I wouldn’t mind a car, but… I don’t know. Now that I’m away, I wish I was back there more than even when I was there. Let’s just say I’m a certain kind of tourist… A tourist that’s on a… permanent vacation.”

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Tom DiCillo’s cinematography

Must See?
No, unless you’re a Jarmusch fan. Listed as a Cult Movie in the back of Peary’s book, which makes sense for the time.

Links:

Red Tent, The (1969)

Red Tent, The (1969)

“When we take up leadership, we forfeit the right to be human — and nobody who’s fit to lead can do that.”

Synopsis:
The guilt-ridden surviving general (Peter Finch) of a dirigible crash near the Arctic in 1928 is visited by ghosts of various people involved in the event — including his pilot (Nikita Mikhalkov), Norwegian explorer Roald Amundsen (Sean Connery), the girlfriend (Claudia Cardinale) of a Swedish meteorologist (Eduard Martsevich), rescue aviator Einar Lundborg (Hardy Kruger), and the chief of the Soviet rescue crew (Grigoriy Gay).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Claudia Cardinale Films
  • Explorers
  • Flashback Films
  • Ghosts
  • Guilt
  • Peter Finch Films
  • Sean Connery Films
  • Search
  • Survival

Review:
This joint Soviet/Italian film was directed by Mikhail Kalatozov and based on a novel crafted from the real-life outcome of the airship Italia (which I hadn’t heard of prior to watching this movie). It’s framed as a flashback tale of survivor’s guilt (17 men died), with Finch (General Nobile) literally haunted by the choices he made each step of the way.

However, the bulk of the movie takes place in exciting location-based action. I’ll cite from Wikipedia’s entry on the film, since it nicely provides an overview of what happens:

The expedition is successful at first, but ends in disaster. The Italia is weighed down when ice forms on it. Colliding with the ground, the airship’s gondola is torn away from its keel and the envelope containing the airship’s hydrogen cells; freed of the weight of the gondola, the rest of the ship floats away and out of control, taking some of Nobile’s crew with it. Nobile maintains control of the surviving crew who are now marooned on arctic pack ice with salvaged supplies. They shelter in a tent that they dye red for visibility. They manage to repair the radio, but after receiving no response to their distress calls, three survivors (Zappi, Mariano, and Malmgren) decide to set off across the ice to seek help.

Much more drama ensues from there — and you’re guaranteed to be kept on the seat of your pants despite knowing the ultimate outcome.

As one can imagine, the shooting schedule for this visually impressive film was truly extensive; according to IMDb’s trivia, “Filming went for 62 weeks” and “included location work in Estonia, the Baltic Sea and the Spitzbergen Archipelago in the Arctic Ocean, and [included] studio work in Moscow and Rome.” While not all of the story is equally compelling (i.e., Cardinale is clearly there simply to provide a female touch):

… it’s worth a look for the footage alone.

Note: It was interesting to learn that “the film was shown in the West and in the USSR in different editing versions and with different soundtracks: in the Soviet version, sounds the music of Aleksandr Zatsepin, in the Italian version [which I watched]: Ennio Morricone’s.”

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • A haunting look at death and survival in the harshest conditions
  • Truly impressive cinematography and location shooting

  • Ennio Morricone’s score

Must See?
Yes, as a fine and ambitious internationally-produced adventure film.

Categories

  • Good Show

Links:

Godfather, Part II, The (1974)

Godfather, Part II, The (1974)

“Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer.”

Synopsis:
After immigrating from Italy as a child (Oreste Baldini), young Vito Corleone (Robert De Niro) rises to a position of power and influence in New York City. Years later, his son Michael (Al Pacino) becomes increasingly alienated from his wife (Diane Keaton) while navigating ongoing tensions in Las Vegas with his brother Fredo (John Cazale), his stepbrother Tom (Robert Duvall), his sister Connie (Talia Shire), and Jewish mob boss Hyman Roth (Lee Strasberg).

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Al Pacino Films
  • Betrayal
  • Diane Keaton Films
  • Family Problems
  • Flashback Films
  • Francis Ford Coppola Films
  • Historical Drama
  • Mafia
  • Marital Problems
  • Robert De Niro Films
  • Robert Duvall Films
  • Siblings
  • Talia Shire Films

Response to Peary’s Review:
Peary is not a huge fan of Francis Ford Coppola’s Oscar-winning follow-up — a combined prequel and sequel — to 1972’s The Godfather. He asserts that “Coppola doesn’t have De Niro or Pacino do much acting, limiting them to little snippets of dialogue and many moments when they react (with quiet, calm voices) to the more emotional and demonstrative peripheral characters around them.” (I disagree, but will keep going with Peary’s assessment.)

He argues that “De Niro gets by on presence alone (his charming smile, his quizzical look, his physical grace), but Pacino is a brooding bore” — a character who “does not develop logically from the person he played in the original,” but rather “is a caricature of a crime boss” (again, I disagree). He adds, “All [the] major scenes seem unreal, calculated for audience response,” and “phoniest of all is his breakup scene with wife Diane Keaton, who looks over-rehearsed, like a scene for an acting class.”

Peary continues his take-down by noting that “several of the major scenes in the contemporary section come across as mere duplications of real-life drama we’ve seen on television,” noting specifically that “the scene in which the senator (G.D. Spradin) is found in a brothel with a hooker he brutally killed is similar to numerous sequences in exploitation films of the era and is included for no reason other than sensationalism.”

He asserts that “the only moments that come across as real are when the crime bosses and legitimate businessmen gather in Batista Cuba to decide how to divide up the American pie”:

… and “when a Jewish crime boss (a terrific, subdued debut performance by legendary acting teacher Lee Strasberg) raises rather than lowers the volume on a televised football game while talking over important crime business with Michael.”

In Alternate Oscars — where he names Chinatown (1974) the Best Picture of the Year instead — Peary concedes that The Godfather, Part II “went a step farther” than the original film “by exploring the link between organized crime and politicians — which was certainly a topical theme in light of the Watergate scandal.”

I — along with most other film lovers and critics — disagree with Peary’s take on this justifiably lauded sequel. It’s equally, if differently, compelling throughout, taking the sprawling storyline in fascinating directions (both backwards and forwards) and continuing to grow our understanding of precisely how a mob family like the Corleones may have evolved. I don’t have any complaints, and find both De Niro and Pacino suitable in their roles; to that end, for another take on the depth of Pacino’s characterization as Michael, check out the video “How Michael Corleone Looks at People”.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Al Pacino as Michael Corleone
  • Robert De Niro as young Vito Corleone
  • Gordon Willis’s cinematography
  • Fine attention to period detail
  • Nino Rota’s score

Must See?
Yes, naturally.

Categories

  • Genuine Classic
  • Oscar Winner or Nominee

(Listed in 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die)

Links:

Femme Douce, Une (1969)

Femme Douce, Une (1969)

“She made me see woman as an instrument of pleasure.”

Synopsis:
A pawnshop owner (Guy Frangin) reflects back on his troubled marriage with a beautiful young woman (Dominique Sanda) who has just killed herself by jumping out a window.

Genres, Themes, Actors, and Directors:

  • Flashback Films
  • French Films
  • Marital Problems
  • Robert Bresson Films
  • Suicide

Review:
Robert Bresson’s ninth of 13 feature-length films was this adaptation of an 1876 short story by Fyodor Dostoevsky called “A Gentle Creature”, which has inspired numerous cinematic renderings (though I’m not sure why). To put it mildly, I’m not a fan of Bresson (I only have one more of his titles left to review — not that I’m counting), so I wouldn’t have liked this movie anyway; but I don’t quite see the appeal of the story itself: a pawnbroker lusts after a beautiful young woman without much money, who he believes he can rescue:

… and then is surprised when she’s not too pleased with his overbearing, objectifying approach to her. Maybe this is a common challenge for some men (“Why isn’t my wife happy? I give her everything she wants and needs…”) but it’s crystal clear that these individuals don’t actually relate to one another in any way except sexually. He’s penny-pinching, she’s inclined to generosity; he likes jazz, she likes classical music; she looks perpetually miserable, he looks perpetually suspicious and sour.

What could go wrong? Well, as we know from the opening scene, pretty much everything, in the worst possible way.

Of course it doesn’t help that Bresson has instructed his actors, as usual, to NOT act, rendering them essentially robotic from the get-go. Skip this one unless you’re a Bresson fan and somehow understand what he’s going for.

Notable Performances, Qualities, and Moments:

  • Ghislain Cloquet’s cinematography

Must See?
No. Listed as a film with Historical Importance and a Personal Recommendation in the back of Peary’s book.

Links: