“It’s all a man’s fault, giving you the wrong start.”
A tugboat captain (George F. Marion) asks his alcoholic mistress (Marie Dressler) to move off his boat when he learns his grown daughter (Greta Garbo) — who he hasn’t seen since she was a young child – is coming to visit him. Garbo keeps her past as a prostitute secret from both her father and a shipwrecked sailor (Charles Bickford) who falls in love with her — but will she eventually be forced to share the unsavory truth of her history?
Clarence Brown’s adaptation of Eugene O’Neill’s Pulitzer Prize-winning play is primarily notable for featuring Greta Garbo speaking on screen for the first time: “Gimme a whisky, ginger ale on the side — and don’t be stingy, baby!” Unfortunately, her strong Swedish accent does her no favors with this kind of slangy American dialogue, which never seems to flow swimmingly from her tongue. However, she exhibits appropriate pathos as a woman caught in a trap not-of-her-own-making: this storyline about a girl abandoned by her father, treated like a slave on a farm owned by her cousins, then raped and forced to conclude she has no other options than to sell her body, is a devastatingly classic tale of women at the mercy of men, unable to shed their past means of survival once they’re ready to move on. Her deluded but well-meaning father naively believes in the purity of both his daughter and farming life — anything but “the old devil sea”, which he blames for his own shiftlessness and inability to provide effective parenting. Meanwhile, Bickford is equally convinced of Garbo’s sanctity; the primary question remains how he’ll handle the truth once or if he hears it. While Anna Christie suffers from overly stage-bound, early-talkie direction, it remains worth a look for those interested in O’Neill’s work.
Note: The scenes involving permanently-soused Dressler are unexpectedly moving, given her overall generosity of spirit.
Redeeming Qualities and Moments:
No, though it’s worth a one-time look. Listed as a film with Historical Importance in the back of Peary’s book.